{"id":7074044,"date":"2026-10-26T18:14:19","date_gmt":"2026-10-26T18:14:19","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044"},"modified":"2026-10-26T18:14:19","modified_gmt":"2026-10-26T18:14:19","slug":"the-american-narrative-episode-5-the-kirk-holden-war","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044","title":{"rendered":"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War"},"content":{"rendered":"<p> <br \/>\n<\/p>\n<div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"zstsn144822\" id=\"viewer-zstsn144822\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>DISCLAIMER (0:00) \u2013 The following program contains descriptions of violence and suggestive topics that may not be appropriate for younger audiences. Listener discretion is advised.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"l0i3f6\" id=\"viewer-l0i3f6\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (0:10) \u2013 You\u2019re listening to The American Narrative: Histories of a Nation, a podcast series by Discover America. I\u2019m your host, Tim Murphy, alongside cohost Grant Shea, ready to deliver another thrilling tale about our nation\u2019s arcane past.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wz94j9\" id=\"viewer-wz94j9\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (0:22) \u2013 I\u2019m excited, man. I\u2019m excited to explore what new and interesting story we got planned this week.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"upc6y11\" id=\"viewer-upc6y11\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (0:28) \u2013 In today\u2019s episode, we continue our journey through the Reconstruction Era South, and investigate the Kirk-Holden War\u2014North Carolina\u2019s counterproductive campaign against Klan violence.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"guj0b13\" id=\"viewer-guj0b13\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (0:39) \u2013 The geopolitics of the American Civil War were kaleidoscopic, far more complex than the rudimentary North-South divide. Ideological differences over loyalty, secession, and the very meaning of war permeated through the Union and Confederacy, creating deep internal divisions within their respective states.\u00a0In North Carolina, these fissures were particularly stark along geographic lines: the state\u2019s coastal plains and mountainous regions generally maintained Unionist sympathies, while the agricultural Piedmont overwhelmingly favored secession.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"160ng17\" id=\"viewer-160ng17\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Amid this turmoil emerged William Woods Holden\u2014 a walking contradiction whose mercurial character encapsulated the shifting tides of North Carolina politics. Holden\u2019s career began in journalism, first apprenticing as a typesetter for the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Hillsborough Recorder<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0and <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Star<\/span><\/em><span>, both pro-Whig newspapers. Yet, when he acquired the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>North Carolina Standard<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0in 1843, he aligned himself with the Democratic Party.\u00a0Holden quickly gained notoriety for his fiercely partisan and provocative editorials, especially among disaffected Whigs, who decried his sectional arguments endorsing state sovereignty and the westward expansion of slavery. Under Holden\u2019s leadership, the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Standard<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0quickly became one of North Carolina\u2019s most widely circulated periodicals, and a valuable mouthpiece for the Democratic Party.\u00a0Holden built a reputation as a political \u201ckingmaker\u201d in antebellum North Carolina, and by the early 1850s, he had risen to chair the Democratic State Executive Committee.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"vw0o631\" id=\"viewer-vw0o631\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In 1858, Holden sought the Democratic nomination for governor. Although he received considerable support from the state\u2019s more populist elements, party leaders selected state superior court Judge John Willis Ellis instead. Later that same year, Holden also lost his bid for the U.S. Senate to Thomas Clingman. These defeats embittered Holden, who blamed elitist ex-Whigs for undermining his political prospects.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"y1oob33\" id=\"viewer-y1oob33\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Following Abraham Lincoln\u2019s election in November 1860, Holden worked vigorously to preserve North Carolina\u2019s status within the Union. He denounced the rhetoric of fire-eaters\u2014a notable departure from his earlier advocacy for states\u2019 rights\u2014and prophesized that secession could spark a devastating civil war.\u00a0This pragmatic, cautious approach alienated many of his remaining Democratic supporters.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"97tla37\" id=\"viewer-97tla37\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Holden maintained his Unionist sympathies through the State Secession Convention of February 1861, leading efforts that repealed North Carolina\u2019s initial ordinance of secession. However, after the attack on Fort Sumter, public sentiment sharply shifted, and Holden wholeheartedly committed himself to the Confederate cause.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"mn2se39\" id=\"viewer-mn2se39\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>But Holden\u2019s support for the Confederacy soon faded. Disillusioned by Jefferson Davis\u2019s insular leadership and incongruous Confederate policies, Holden organized a new \u201cConservative\u201d Party that opposed the incumbent state government led by Governor Henry Toole Clark. Ironically, many beneficiaries of this conservative campaign were old-line Whigs who had opposed Holden during the antebellum period.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"4b0eo41\" id=\"viewer-4b0eo41\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>With support from former Whigs, Holden endorsed Zebulon B. Vance\u2014a Confederate colonel and former U.S. Congressman\u2014as the Conservative candidate for governor. Vance handily won the election and initially enjoyed a close working relationship with Holden. By 1863, however, disagreements over the war\u2019s direction caused their alliance to unravel.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"71an544\" id=\"viewer-71an544\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Holden, increasingly influenced by the Peace Platform, argued that North Carolina should independently negotiate an armistice as a means to overcome Richmond&#8217;s blind obstinance, mitigate further destruction, and secure favorable terms with the federal government. He maintained that it was better to secure an honorable peace than risk unconditional surrender\u2014a view that resonated with deserters, draft dodgers, and Unionists alike.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"mp5pq46\" id=\"viewer-mp5pq46\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Vance strongly disagreed, believing that peace should be pursued in cooperation with other Confederate states. Unable to dissuade Holden, Vance severed political ties and denounced the peace movement as dangerous and subversive. Said Vance: \u201cI will see the Conservative party blown into a thousand atoms\u2014and Holden and his understrappers in Hell\u2014before I will consent to a course, which I think, will bring dishonor and ruin upon the state and the Confederacy!\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"hnxed48\" id=\"viewer-hnxed48\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In 1864, Holden turned the peace platform into a political campaign, challenging Vance in that year\u2019s gubernatorial election. However, many former Whigs\u2014once integral to the Conservative Party\u2019s success\u2014joined Democrats and branded Holden as a traitor to the Confederacy. Vance ultimately defeated Holden in a landslide victory, receiving over eighty percent of the vote.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"dw97650\" id=\"viewer-dw97650\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (5:08) \u2013 You know what you find a lot of the times? A lot of the times the politicians or the leaders whose whole platform is built on peace or on just stability\u2014or really just \u2018put your head in the sand and don\u2019t look around\u2019\u2014like, it\u2019s not a long-term platform. And it\u2019s really just because dynamics and society and demographics\u2014everything is constantly in flux and changing. And so it\u2019s hard to even conceptualize what peace in one instance looks like as opposed to the next, and\u2026Peace for the sake of peace, right? It\u2019s like, you can\u2019t\u2026sometimes there\u2019s an unjust peace or\u2026I feel like at the end of the day, you got to\u2014there\u2019s got to be principle beyond just the avoidance of conflict, because conflict is part of human nature. You got to figure out whose conflict is more justified and, you know, try to make is as equitable and fair as possible. But, it\u2019s just like, you know, \u201cmy whole platform is peace\u201d\u2014You just don\u2019t see it long-term working in a lot of situations. I think it\u2019s an admirable, noble goal and aspiration, but it\u2019s just\u2014it doesn\u2019t seem to be that effective throughout the annals of history.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ff2x752\" id=\"viewer-ff2x752\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (6:27) \u2013 Yeah, and there&#8217;s something to be said, too, about pacifism and abstaining from violence; like that&#8217;s all admirable. And I think\u2014as it relates to the disagreement between Holden and Vance\u2014Holden could see the forest for the trees, right? He saw that the Confederacy couldn&#8217;t outlast the Union, and he was like, &#8216;We should get ahead of this. We should negotiate our own peace to avoid this destructive war and any unfavorable terms of surrender.&#8217; But Vance was like, &#8216;Absolutely not. We made a pact with these other southern states. We must abide by what the Confederacy collectively decides.&#8217;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"p4twa57\" id=\"viewer-p4twa57\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (7:04) \u2013 But I&#8217;m sure you can already appreciate Holden&#8217;s tendency to contradict his previous positions, and we&#8217;re not even out of the Civil War yet.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"9jqjm60\" id=\"viewer-9jqjm60\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (7:13) \u2013 Yeah, I was getting\u2014I had an inkling. Interesting.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"njh5r62\" id=\"viewer-njh5r62\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (7:18) \u2013 Despite this setback, Holden\u2019s prospects for executive authority were not completely exhausted. After the Confederacy collapsed, President Andrew Johnson appointed him as North Carolina\u2019s provisional governor on May 29, 1865.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"pzd2264\" id=\"viewer-pzd2264\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Democrats and ex-Confederates seethed with resentment at Holden&#8217;s appointment. One detractor remarked: \u201c[The conquerors] have taken the lowest, most abject, and degraded man they could find amongst us\u2014one Holden\u2014and exalted him to the post of provisional Governor\u2014a base born bastard with neither the breeding [nor] the instincts of a gentleman\u2026\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wpudc67\" id=\"viewer-wpudc67\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>While Holden\u2019s tenure as provisional governor was rather unremarkable, he did wield significant power by securing pardons for many former Confederates, thereby restoring their political franchise. He also filled government vacancies with loyal supporters, drawing contempt from Conservative opponents.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"9ki4v69\" id=\"viewer-9ki4v69\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>During a special gubernatorial election in December 1865, the Conservative Party nominated State Treasurer Jonathan Worth to run against Holden. As a state senator, Worth staunchly opposed North Carolina\u2019s withdrawal from the Union and was one of only three lawmakers who rejected the final ordinance of secession. Nevertheless, he remained loyal to North Carolina throughout the conflict. Under the Vance administration, Worth became the public treasurer, where he exercised conservative fiscal management and frequently quarreled with Confederate treasury officials.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"grsdy71\" id=\"viewer-grsdy71\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Despite his relative obscurity, Worth defeated Holden, and the Conservatives swept into power. President Johnson later appointed Holden as Minister to El Salvador, but the Senate refused to confirm him. Holden eventually returned to editing the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>North Carolina Standard<\/span><\/em><span>.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"c2ygi75\" id=\"viewer-c2ygi75\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In 1867, Congress passed the Reconstruction Acts, which placed the former Confederate states under military occupation\u2014North Carolina was placed in the Second Military District, alongside South Carolina. These measures not only disenfranchised many former Confederates, but also required states to revise their constitutions and ratify the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments, which secured citizenship and suffrage for newly emancipated blacks.\u00a0During this period, Holden once again shifted his political allegiances. Backed by northern carpetbaggers and a sizeable African American coalition, he helped organize the state Republican Party. Holden also presided over the North Carolina Union League\u2014a fraternal organization that mobilized freedmen to support Republican candidates and initiatives. Nearly forty percent of the state\u2019s black population joined the League, making its support indispensable to Republican success.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"vhqph79\" id=\"viewer-vhqph79\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Conservatives responded to the Union League\u2019s influence by supporting the Ku Klux Klan, a white supremacist organization that used violence and intimidation to \u201cremove the dark savages and white ignoramuses wearing the oath of office\u201d\u2014simply put, to suppress black and Republican political participation.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lb22z81\" id=\"viewer-lb22z81\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>First appearing in 1868, the North Carolina Klan was not a single militant arm, but rather three loosely organized groups: the White Brotherhood, the Invisible Empire, and the Constitutional Union Guard (or CUG). Although Klan activity occurred across the state, it was especially concentrated in predominantly white, agrarian counties of the Piedmont region.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"qmpsj83\" id=\"viewer-qmpsj83\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (10:29) \u2013 I just want to point out, too, like some of these names, they just sound foreboding. They just sound intimidating.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wu4c385\" id=\"viewer-wu4c385\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (10:37) \u2013 Yeah, you know what\u2019s funny is a lot of these racist, sexist\u2014whatever organizations they are that really rely on violence to perpetuate injustice and inequality\u2014their names are deliberately designed to evoke fear or evoke like a sense of, as you said, foreboding. It\u2019s almost like a branding. It\u2019s like marketing. It\u2019s like, \u2018all right, well, you know, our whole structure is based on violence and fear. That\u2019s how we perpetuate injustice. And we need to have a name that demonstrates our values, and our values being fear, violence, and\u2026\u2019 It\u2019s not surprising, right, that they, like as you just said, they deliberately\u2014everything is deliberate. It makes sense, but, it\u2019s usually just masking an insecurity. Oppression is the mask of fear.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"imynl87\" id=\"viewer-imynl87\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (11:34) \u2013 Against this politically and racially-charged backdrop, the North Carolina Constitutional Convention convened on January 14, 1868. These proceedings were largely dominated by Republicans, Unionists, and free blacks who were overwhelmingly sympathetic to the tenets of Congressional Reconstruction. The new state constitution abolished slavery, guaranteed universal male suffrage, eliminated property and religious qualifications for voting and officeholding, and authorized the creation of a &#8220;general and uniform system of Public Schools&#8221; open to both African Americans and whites.\u00a0\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"rx3z689\" id=\"viewer-rx3z689\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>While the final constitutional draft was being prepared, Holden received the Republican nomination for governor. During the April 1868 referendum, North Carolinians ratified the new constitution and elected Holden to the governorship, defeating Conservative opponent Thomas Samuel Ashe by more than 18,000 votes. Governor Worth refused to concede to \u201cNorth Carolina\u2019s malicious prince of demagoguism,\u201d \u00a0but ultimately relinquished his office under protest on July 1, citing \u201cmilitary duress\u201d imposed by General Edward Canby, commander of the Second Military District. Holden was formally inaugurated on July 4, the same day North Carolina regained admission to the Union.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"phlai91\" id=\"viewer-phlai91\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Holden\u2019s ascension and support for what many Democrats considered an illegal constitution fanned the flames of vituperation, especially from Josiah Turner, Jr., the acerbic editor of the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>, North Carolina\u2019s leading Conservative newspaper. Turner\u2014a caustic and uncompromising enemy of Radical Reconstruction\u2014castigated all North Carolina Republicans, Holden in particular. The animosity was likely personal in nature, as suggested by <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>The Western Democrat<\/span><\/em><span>, dated November 7, 1865:\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ys1mv97\" id=\"viewer-ys1mv97\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>\u201cMr. Josiah Turner, of Orange County, a candidate for Congress in the Raleigh District, drew up a petition for pardon, in which he bitterly assailed the old Democratic party, and falsely accused it of bringing all the evils upon the country. And then he had the impudence to ask Governor Holden to endorse if favorably. The Governor very properly refused to recommend the petition of a man who was so full of party malice, and the result is that the \u201cso-called\u201d Honorable Josiah Turner is opposing Governor Holden with all his might.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"cedjh99\" id=\"viewer-cedjh99\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>It is said that Mr. Turner\u2019s petition for pardon covered forty foolscap pages, filled with party slang and denunciation\u2014nothing more than a reflection upon and insult to the Governor and President. If a man feels compelled to ask pardon, propriety at least would suggest that he refrain from abuse and denunciation of those whom he is asking a favor.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"llr5q103\" id=\"viewer-llr5q103\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (14:12) \u2013 Turner was a master of polemical journalism, and routinely used the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span> to ridicule the Holden administration, often stooping to personal invectives. Here are just a couple of examples of Turner\u2019s admonishment.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"os9e7107\" id=\"viewer-os9e7107\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The first\u2014drawn from the Daily Sentinel, dated December 17, 1868\u2014describes Holden\u2019s ineptitude for the state\u2019s high office: \u201cMany of Governor Holden\u2019s friends do not hesitate openly to express their disappointment at the weakness and lack of judgement displaying in his administration of the Executive office. Why they should be thus disappointed, we are unable to comprehend. Any man, who observed with half an eye, the manner in which he conducted the Provisional regime, ought to have been prepared for the imbecility and narrow partisanship which he has exhibited in his present, more enlarged field of power and duty.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"08kz2109\" id=\"viewer-08kz2109\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>No one will deny to him flat-rate talent as a party newspaper paragraphist and as a shrewd political manager, where other interests than his own are involved. But when the latter is the case, he becomes actually stupid in his bunglings; and hence, it is that, inflated with conceit, that he could signalize the office\u2026[H]e has done nothing but blunder and boggle from the start.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ant4z111\" id=\"viewer-ant4z111\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The Guardian of the State\u2019s interests, he has allied himself with the horde of carpet bag adventurers who have infested the land, and who are running the ship upon the rocks, with a consenting pilot at the helm.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"r05ul115\" id=\"viewer-r05ul115\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (15:33) \u2013 So, that\u2019s number one.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"8ipgo117\" id=\"viewer-8ipgo117\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (15:36) \u2013 The second example comes from the Weekly Sentinel, dated March 16, 1869. Here, Turner speculates the Republican Party\u2019s ulterior motives behind the Fifteenth Amendment:<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"bembr119\" id=\"viewer-bembr119\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>\u201cAnyone unacquainted with the political history of our time\u2026would very naturally suppose that the party that foisted [this] amendment upon the American people was indeed the unfaltering and honest friend of the negro\u2026[and] that it was a resultant of the most unfeigned friendship for the inferior race. But he would soon find\u2026that all this ostensible sympathy with, and love for, the negro and his rights, were the merest sentimental vaporing and rant, and meant nothing seriously.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"6vud6121\" id=\"viewer-6vud6121\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The right to vote is given; the above amendment guarantees that, but how about the right to hold office? It is not [supposed] that \u201cthe friend and brother\u201d shall be President, or Congressman, or Governor\u2026The poor credulous negro may be used in advancing the selfish schemes of political emissaries and propagandists\u2026The balance of power is in the negro\u2019s hand, but like a simpleton, he pliantly obeys what his white leader says; he votes like an automation moved by the hands of the political juggler, and quietly takes a seat out in the dark and cold, whilst his \u201cso-called\u201d white ally and friend is snugly ensconced in the chimney corner of some lucrative office.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"4g51i124\" id=\"viewer-4g51i124\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Yes, the poor, deluded negroes may vote; nay, it is their inalienable right, quoth the great Radical Smelfungus, but they shall not have offices, and if they perchance should get offices, they must be \u201cpoor ones\u201d\u2026Such is the platform of Radicals.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"e8mhg126\" id=\"viewer-e8mhg126\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (17:04) \u2013 You know, I think they\u2014this is the kind of history that people need to be taught if they\u2019re growing up in America, right? It\u2019s like, if you have a soul, and you have any moral principles\u2014you hear something like that, and it\u2019s just\u2014the emotions that it brings out, it\u2019s hard to articulate, but it\u2019s just so antithetical to the words written in the Declaration, or the founding principles\u2014the bedrock of the country\u2014that we aspire to be. It\u2019s almost like\u2026it\u2019s hard. It\u2019s just so hard to reconcile that kind of rhetoric and that kind of opinion with what the nation is supposed to aspire to be. It\u2019s just heartbreaking, but, it is what it was, you know? People thought like that, and you can\u2019t shy away from it.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"5i8pj128\" id=\"viewer-5i8pj128\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (17:56) \u2013 Yeah, and it&#8217;s like a very underhanded critique, too. Like, he&#8217;s saying, &#8216;Yeah, you got the right to vote, but you&#8217;re naive to think that the Republicans will support you if you try to run for office.&#8217; Which\u2014that&#8217;s a fair assessment, but not coming from someone who&#8217;s a member of the Democratic-Conservative Party, like\u2014would you vote for them, or even support enfranchisement in the first place? No, I don&#8217;t think so.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"at2c7133\" id=\"viewer-at2c7133\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (18:22) \u2013 And also\u2014the language that Turner uses\u2014there are overt implications of racial inferiority, like how African Americans are being puppeteered by the Republican Party, but they&#8217;re too ignorant or too simple-minded to realize what&#8217;s going on. So, you can see the type of rhetoric Mr. Turner liked to espouse.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lrenx137\" id=\"viewer-lrenx137\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (18:43) \u2013 Oh, yeah.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lchhh139\" id=\"viewer-lchhh139\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (18:44) \u2013 And these are just two of honestly thousands of examples you can find.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"anm8s142\" id=\"viewer-anm8s142\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (18:48) \u2013 And you know, you think, right? That\u2019s your legacy. You know, 160 years from now, two guys are going to be on a podcast and they\u2019re going to be reading what you wrote, and that\u2019s what you chose to leave behind. It\u2019s just the ash heap of history, you know? It\u2019s like, all right\u2026what does that leave behind? What good is that? It\u2019s fear. It\u2019s all fear. It\u2019s fear of losing privilege. I mean that\u2019s what\u2014fear of discomfort\u2026Again, we can\u2019t shy away from it, you know? The good, the bad, and the ugly. And there are\u2014there\u2019s good. I hate when people just summarily dismiss like, no\u2014that\u2019s not what it means to be a human. Like, there\u2019s a reason the scales of justice, they\u2019re scales, right? Everything\u2019s relative, and everything\u2026you have to train yourself, and you have to be rooted in defensible moral values to discern good and bad\u2014degrees of good, degrees of bad\u2014and, you know, context. I think that\u2019s what history does, man. And that\u2019s what these podcasts and what you\u2019re\u2014you do such an amazing job at, is it\u2019s just like\u2014going back to the roots of what it means to be a human and thinking about and reading what other people said and how they reached their opinions, their perspectives, their conclusions, and then figuring out the truth based on a plethora of different perspectives.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"37py2144\" id=\"viewer-37py2144\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (20:07) \u2013 I also think that we should bring back the term \u2018Smelfungus\u2019 as an insult.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"xyzyo146\" id=\"viewer-xyzyo146\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (20:14) \u2013 Smelfungus. I\u2019ve never heard that before, but I\u2019m using that now. That\u2019s definitely\u2014that\u2019s been added to my repertoire. I\u2019m going to\u2026I guess it\u2019s like a smelly fungus? Just like someone who sucks? Like, I mean\u2026you Smelfungus! It almost sounds like a Harry Potter spell.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"r6oyb150\" id=\"viewer-r6oyb150\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (20:34) \u2013 Yeah. Smelfungus!<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wym5t152\" id=\"viewer-wym5t152\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (20:39) \u2013 Some Republicans referred to Turner as \u201cKing of the Ku Klux\u201d due to his provocative language. Although no definitive evidence exists linking Turner to the Klan, his incendiary rhetoric almost certainly fomented political extremism in the Piedmont.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"redc2154\" id=\"viewer-redc2154\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On the night of January 24, 1869, approximately three dozen members of the Lenoir County Constitutional Union Guard kidnapped five men\u2014four black and one white\u2014from the Kinston jail. The abducted prisoners\u2014Richard Noble, Robin Grady, Cato Grady, John Miller, and Daniel Smith\u2014were taken to a nearby bridge and executed; their bodies dumped into the Neuse River.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"z36vj156\" id=\"viewer-z36vj156\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Within days of this vigilantism, the Moore County Klan committed one of the most heinous crimes in North Carolina\u2019s history. On a cold winter\u2019s night, at least thirteen masked men stormed the home of Daniel Blue, a black man, and indiscriminately starting shooting. As the gun smoke settled, Blue lay upon the floor, shot but not mortally wounded. His family, however, was not so lucky; Blue&#8217;s pregnant wife and four of his five children were slain. When the attackers discovered that Blue&#8217;s fifth child was still alive, one of the Klansmen proceeded to &#8220;[kick] its brains out with the heel of his boot,&#8221; killing the child.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"alh66158\" id=\"viewer-alh66158\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In an attempt to cover up their crime, the culprits set fire to Blue&#8217;s home with the bodies of his family still inside. Remarkably, Daniel Blue escaped with his life. The Klan never offered any specific reason for its attack on the Blue family, but their actions were intended as a brutal reminder to ensure that blacks \u201cknew their place.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lgfyi160\" id=\"viewer-lgfyi160\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (22:11) \u2013 That\u2019s just awful.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"jonaf162\" id=\"viewer-jonaf162\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (22:13) \u2013 Yeah, I mean it\u2019s like satanic, or it\u2019s just evil\u2014evil and cruelty. It\u2019s just basically like where you can\u2019t make a good enough argument, and you can\u2019t\u2014and empathy, and law, and justice, and none of that\u2019s on your side. This is violence. It\u2019s like the brute force method. It\u2019s like the schoolyard bully that, you know, you just\u2026I don\u2019t know. \u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"c6uu8164\" id=\"viewer-c6uu8164\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (22:39) \u2013 Local authorities were often unwilling or unable\u2014either by collusion or intimidation\u2014to prosecute Klan-related offenses, which placed even more pressure on the state government to protect its citizens.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"0zsp0168\" id=\"viewer-0zsp0168\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>As a practical matter, on February 19, 1869, the General Assembly passed the \u201cAct to Prescribe the Power and Duty of the Governor in Respect to Fugitives from Justice,&#8221; which empowered Holden to \u201cemploy a detective force, as he may deem sufficient, to pursue and apprehend any felon who is a fugitive from justice, within or without the limits of the State.\u201d The newly established detective agency operated under North Carolina Adjutant General Abial W. Fisher, a former Union officer.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"9n0ui170\" id=\"viewer-9n0ui170\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Despite the efforts of state-sanctioned investigators, white extremists continued to operate with relative impunity. On May 1, 1869, Sheriff Orson R. Colgrove arrested two CUG members\u2014Ash Devane and James Hines\u2014for mule theft and placed them in the Jones County jail. Two days later, the CUG orchestrated a jailbreak, freeing Devane and Hines from custody. Motivated by their animosity, the CUG later ambushed and killed Sheriff Colgrove on a public road near Trenton.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"y3okz172\" id=\"viewer-y3okz172\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0issued a quasi-sympathetic editorial following Colgrove\u2019s murder: \u201cWe regretted deeply to hear of the killing of Sheriff Colgrove, of Jones [County]. Scarcely anything but the most flagrant violation of official duty and the prostitution of one\u2019s office to the worst purposes can palliate, much less justify, the enormous offense of killing an officer of the law.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ubqy3178\" id=\"viewer-ubqy3178\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>We have heard, however, of several instances in the State, in which carpetbag and scalawag Sheriffs and Deputies seem to have combined to distress and worry the people. Public officers who do this not only subject themselves to merited censure, but they may [also] expect fierce retaliation\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"5rys5180\" id=\"viewer-5rys5180\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The [killing of Sheriff Colgrove] itself was a high crime, a heinous offense which deserves punishment, but the summary manner in which the colored and white friends of Sheriff Colgrove are acting, professedly with the view of getting at the guilty party, is outrageous, lawless, and wicked, and ought to be suppressed\u2026If justified by the authorities, the next thing we shall hear of will be open civil war in the State.\u201d\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"398qe183\" id=\"viewer-398qe183\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Following the Colgrove murder, Judge Charles Randolph Thomas, Jr. issued a formal appeal to Governor Holden, requesting military assistance to reestablish law and order. Holden obliged and appointed R. T. Bosher\u2014a former state detective\u2014 to lead a militia company of 25 men into Jones County.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"tncgj185\" id=\"viewer-tncgj185\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The presence of militia temporarily stopped the violence, but the Klan inevitably renewed their threats against Republican officials. M. L. Shepard explained the situation to Holden: &#8220;One week ago yesterday, notices were found posted on trees in this neighborhood that D.D. Colgrove, L.D. Wilkie, and M.L. Shepard must leave the county before the first day of September, or else they would be removed by death\u2026When I am killed (doing my duty), and in defense of the Law, then my Friends will have to take my place\u2026&#8221; Shepard was subsequently gunned down at his sawmill on August 16.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"r3743187\" id=\"viewer-r3743187\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Klan outrages only intensified during the latter half of 1869. One of the most widely publicized acts of violence involved Alonzo B. Corliss of Alamance County\u2014a \u201ccrippled carpetbagger\u201d from Vermont who led a local Union League and taught black children at a Quaker school in Company Shops. On November 26, several disguised men abducted Corliss, brutally beat him in a nearby forest, and threatened to kill him if he did not leave the area.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"hjicy189\" id=\"viewer-hjicy189\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Corliss detailed his encounter with the Klan four days later: &#8220;We are in trouble. Five men disguised in a Satanic garb&#8230;dragged me from my bed and bore me roughly in double quick time one-and-a-half miles to a thicket, whipped me unmercifully and left me to die. They demanded of me that I should cease &#8216;teaching [negros]\u2019 and leave in ten days or be treated worse\u2026I am not able to sit up yet. I shall never recover from all my injuries.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lauqr193\" id=\"viewer-lauqr193\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (26:36) \u2013 I honestly didn&#8217;t realize how many examples of racial violence I included in this episode. But now after reading it through, there&#8217;s quite a lot.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"8fnp6196\" id=\"viewer-8fnp6196\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (26:49) \u2013 And that was their one weapon. I mean, it was just fear and violence. It\u2019s a tale as old as time, unfortunately, but what I will say is\u2014these concrete examples, you know, these experiences that people went through and the pain and the suffering that they\u2014they communicated, they shared, they felt\u2014I mean\u2026it\u2019s important that it\u2019s never glossed over, right? There\u2019s one way to honor people\u2019s suffering and it\u2019s to not forget it, and it\u2019s to make sure it\u2019s shared. These are stories that aren\u2019t shared enough because they\u2019re uncomfortable for certain people, but they are the most human and most deeply, in some ways, American stories that need to be shared. \u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fe8nr198\" id=\"viewer-fe8nr198\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (27:38) \u2013 With Klan enormity spreading across the Piedmont, Governor Holden urged the General Assembly to strengthen the state\u2019s &#8220;Fugitives from Justice\u201d law. He cited \u201cnumerous complaints\u2026of violence and mob law in certain counties, by parties who ride at night armed and disguised&#8230;injuring, insulting, and punishing inoffensive whites and colored persons.&#8221; \u00a0Only by expanding militia powers, Holden argued, could North Carolina effectively punish offenders in areas where civil authority was failing.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"g38mw200\" id=\"viewer-g38mw200\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On December 16, 1869, State Senator T. M. Shoffner introduced &#8220;An Act to Secure the Better Protection of Life and Property\u201d\u2014later dubbed the Shoffner Act. This bill gave Holden the executive prerogative to \u201cdeclare [any] county to be in a state of insurrection and to call into active service the militia of the state to such an extent as may become necessary to suppress such insurrection.&#8221; The act also authorized Holden to suspend of habeas corpus\u2014the legal protection against unlawful detention\u2014\u201cwhenever, in his judgement, the civil authorities\u2026are unable to protect its citizens in the enjoyment of life and property,\u201d and request federal assistance if the state militia proved inadequate.\u00a0The bill faced determined resistance from Conservative legislators, who argued that suspending habeas corpus violated constitutional rights. After removing this controversial provision, the legislature ratified the Shoffner Act on January 29, 1870.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"pw61k204\" id=\"viewer-pw61k204\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The Klan reacted with outrage. In Alamance County, several Klansmen plotted to kill Shoffner in his home. However, Captain Eli Euliss\u2014a high-ranking member of the Alamance Klan and personal friend of Shoffner&#8217;s\u2014learned of the plot and persuaded the senator to accompany him to Greensboro. The plan dissolved after Shoffner\u2019s escape, but he continued to receive death threats and eventually fled to Indiana.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"02rf5206\" id=\"viewer-02rf5206\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>During the same period, Klansmen in Moore County conspired to murder Governor Holden. John Barrett, one of Holden&#8217;s informants, later testified about a clandestine meeting of the Moore County Klan, where several members &#8220;agreed to assassinate Governor Holden by going to his mansion about dark and pretending to have business of importance with him\u2026and when he made his appearance, to shoot him and then make their escape as best they could.&#8221; Their plans floundered soon thereafter, and the plot was ultimately abandoned.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"l9pmo209\" id=\"viewer-l9pmo209\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Unfortunately, Ku Klux violence continued to escalate following the passage of the Shoffner Act. On the evening of February 26, 1870, one hundred masked Klansmen descended on Graham, Alamance County, and abducted Wyatt Outlaw\u2014a Union veteran, town commissioner, and deputy member of the Union League\u2019s Grand State Council. The white vigilantes dragged Outlaw to the town square, lynched him within sight of the courthouse, and pinned a note to his corpse that read, &#8220;Beware, you guilty, both white and black.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"9nffd211\" id=\"viewer-9nffd211\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Despite the atrociousness of Outlaw\u2019s lynching, Democratic-Conservative publications, like the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Hillsborough Recorder<\/span><\/em><span>, could not resist espousing wild conspiracy theories:\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"sstpp216\" id=\"viewer-sstpp216\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>\u201cIt is represented to us that about one o\u2019clock last Saturday night, a disguised body of seventy-five or a hundred men appeared at the house of Henry Holt, colored, and entered his house, where they found not Holt, but an aged negro man named [Wyatt Outlaw]\u2026The intention seems to have been to hang both Holt and Outlaw, coachmakers working in co-partnership, but they seem to have swapped beds if not \u201cfamilies\u201d that night, and not knowing the whereabouts of Holt, they did not search for him outside of his premises. They, however, took Outlaw and the cord out of the bed, mounted him on a mule, and hung him with the bed cord to an oak limb in front of the Court house door, where he was found the next morning\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"arejb219\" id=\"viewer-arejb219\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>It is also represented to us that Outlaw\u2019s wife at the inquest swore positively that the first man that took hold on Outlaw was a negro, and that she believes a majority, if not all of them, were colored\u2014Outlaw was the generalissimo or President of the [Union] League, in command of the funds which he was in the habit of stealing or appropriating to his own use.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"4rbqy223\" id=\"viewer-4rbqy223\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Now, whether this diabolical outrage was committed by the Ku Klux or by the Loyal League\u2026for embezzling funds\u2026it was a high-handed outrage against the Law, the Peace and Dignity of the State, and the perpetrators should be ferreted out and dealt with according to law. Such deeds as this will not only prevent Northern men coming here and settling, but will drive off [the] desirable population, disgrace society, and tarnish the escutcheon of the State.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"6112s225\" id=\"viewer-6112s225\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (31:51) \u2013 \u201cDesirable\u201d\u2014that\u2019s always a\u2026what [are] desirable parts of society? These coded words, I\u2019m always like hmm.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"7184x227\" id=\"viewer-7184x227\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (32:04) \u2013 Less than two weeks later, the body of another black man, William Puryear, was found in a nearby millpond. Puryear, who was mentally disabled, had claimed to have recognized of two of Outlaw&#8217;s killers.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"4ck5f229\" id=\"viewer-4ck5f229\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On March 7, Holden declared Alamance County to be in a state of insurrection. As part of his proclamation, Holden asserted: \u201cI have waited to see if the people of Alamance would assemble in public meeting and express their condemnation of such conduct by a portion of the citizens of the County, but I have waited in vain. No meeting of the kind has been held. No expression of disapproval even of such conduct by the great body of the citizens has yet reached this Department; but, on the contrary, it is believed that the lives of citizens who have reported these crimes to the Executive have been thereby endangered, and it is further believed that many of the citizens of the County are so terrified that they dare not complain, or attempt the arrest of criminals in their midst. The civil officers of the County are silent and powerless.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"cx5pa233\" id=\"viewer-cx5pa233\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Hoping to deter further violence, Holden dispatched forty federal troops from Raleigh to Alamance County. The commanding lieutenant persuaded the local magistrate to issue warrants for twelve men suspected in various murders, but these charges were dropped when other citizens provided alibis and issued death threats against civil officials.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"oaffe235\" id=\"viewer-oaffe235\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Klan intimidation left state and local authorities powerless to act, pushing Holden to seek federal intervention.\u00a0Mindful that the Shoffner Act did not empower him as governor to suspend habeas corpus, Holden pleaded with President Ulysses S. Grant: \u201cIf Congress would authorize the suspension by the President of the writ of habeas corpus in certain localities, and if criminals could be arrested and tried before military tribunals, and shot, we would soon have peace and order throughout all this country.\u201d Grant sympathized with Holden\u2019s concerns and sent more federal troops to North Carolina, but took no further steps.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"dhzwa238\" id=\"viewer-dhzwa238\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Still seeking support, Holden sent Adjutant General Fisher to Richmond, Virginia, to request additional reinforcements from Major General Canby. However, Canby was not convinced that Alamance County was truly experiencing an insurrection, and informed Fisher that only the president could authorize additional military intervention.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ltuxt240\" id=\"viewer-ltuxt240\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Meanwhile in Caswell County, John Walter Stephens\u2014a Republican State Senator and outspoken advocate for freedmen&#8217;s rights\u2014grew increasingly concerned for his safety. A former Freedmen\u2019s Bureau agent and Union League organizer, Stephens was integral in mobilizing the county\u2019s majority black electorate. His willingness to openly associate with black residents earned their trust, culminating in his victory over Conservative candidate Bedford Brown during the 1868 state senate race.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"8aile242\" id=\"viewer-8aile242\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>White residents came to despise Stephens, branding him a racial and political renegade. The county became a breeding ground for rumors, many of which were completely unsubstantiated. Allegations ranged from claims that Stephens acted as a spy for Governor Holden, to accusations of bribery and arson. But perhaps the most outlandish charge was that Stephens had committed matricide. On June 30, 1869, Stephens\u2019s mother was found dead in her bedroom with her throat cut. Although the coroner ruled her death accidental\u2014attributing it to a fall on a broken pottery shard\u2014the suspicious circumstances fueled speculation.\u00a0Political adversaries weaponized the tragedy, using it to further attack his reputation.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"u1krn246\" id=\"viewer-u1krn246\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Democrats relentlessly attacked Stephens\u2019s character, often referring to him as \u201cChicken\u201d Stephens. Now, this was not an affront to cowardice or mediocrity. In 1866, authorities in Rockingham County indicted Stephens for killing his neighbor\u2019s chickens after they destroyed his garden. Following his release from jail, Stephens retaliated by caning the neighbor. When bystanders attempted to intervene, Stephens\u2019s pistol accidentally discharged, injuring two men. The incident became a lasting source of political mockery.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"qvwzk249\" id=\"viewer-qvwzk249\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>By the spring of 1870, tensions in Caswell County had reached their breaking point. Stephens wrote to Governor Holden, warning &#8220;we are unable to administer the laws, we feel that unless we can get our county under Military rule, we cannot protect our people.\u201d As a result of repeated threats, Stephens insured his life, fortified his home, and carried three pistols on his person.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"qx5an251\" id=\"viewer-qx5an251\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On May 21, Stephens attended the Democratic nominating convention at the Caswell County Courthouse. After observing the proceedings, he accompanied Frank A. Wiley\u2014a Democrat and former sheriff\u2014to the building\u2019s ground floor. Hoping to bridge the partisan divide, Stephens reportedly offered Wiley political support should he seek reelection. Unbeknownst to Stephens, Wiley had conspired with the Klan to lure him into a deadly trap. The two men entered a vacant storeroom, where a dozen Klansmen lay in wait. One assailant, G. T. Mitchell, held a rope around Stephens&#8217;s neck, while another, Tom Oliver, stabbed him to death. According to John Lea, founder of the local Klan chapter, Stephens was \u201ctried by the Ku Klux Klan and sentenced to death. He had a fair trial before a jury of twelve men.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"pvzyr254\" id=\"viewer-pvzyr254\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>When Stephens failed to return home that evening, his brothers and friends searched the courthouse. They attempted to enter a locked room on the first floor but could not get in, so several men stood guard overnight. The next morning, one of Stephens\u2019s friends glimpsed through a window and saw a body lying behind a wood pile. After forcing their way inside, they confirmed that it was Stephens: deceased.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ycjqb256\" id=\"viewer-ycjqb256\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>\u201cTreachery, treason, and murder have done their work,\u201d exclaimed the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Daily Standard<\/span><\/em><span>. \u201cA State Senator has been ruthlessly assassinated, not in the night-time by masked ruffians, but in the light of day, in the very precincts of a house dedicated to law, peace, and justice. Standing as a spectator in a Democratic meeting, he is decoyed to his death. He is stabbed and hung and the murder is concealed until the villains who perpetrated it escaped. Deliberate, cold, and malicious, planned with all the ingenuity of demons, place and hour chosen, the murderers of Stephens are members of a political klan, the record of whose deeds excel the ghastly stories of fiction, and who are to a man perjurers, robbers, murders, and sworn traitors.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"2a7vx260\" id=\"viewer-2a7vx260\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>What should have sparked collective condemnation instead elicited denialism, followed by misplaced blame in the Conservative press. As the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Wilmington Journal<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0reported: \u201cWe clipped yesterday a report from the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Standard<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0to the effect that J.W. Stephens, Radical Senator from Caswell county, had been taken from his home and murdered, but that paper of yesterday\u2019s date, does not confirm its previous report. It was probably an altogether sensational affair, gotten up for the purpose of further inflaming the Radical mind, and, of course, thereby making more capital for that infamous party to work on. Stephens was probably shot and hung in effigy, and not in reality. While we believe that he fully deserves, for his many atrocities, a far worse punishment than death, and do not care how soon he is called to his final account\u2026we most positively and emphatically denounce any violence at the hands of private parties.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fspqf266\" id=\"viewer-fspqf266\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (38:53) \u2013 How can you say that and then\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"x4bsr268\" id=\"viewer-x4bsr268\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (38:58) \u2013 We do not condone violence in any way, but we\u2019ll accept it if it happens.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"sil1p272\" id=\"viewer-sil1p272\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (39:05) \u2013 Exactly! Death isn\u2019t a good enough punishment, and we hope he, whatever. Blah, blah, blah. But hey, disclaimer: we\u2019re not advocating. But it\u2019s like, all right\u2026oh man.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"nwczx274\" id=\"viewer-nwczx274\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (39:22) \u2013 However, once the crime had been confirmed, the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>New York Herald<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0took to conspiracy: \u201cFor the murder of Senator Stephens, it cannot be ascertained who is directly responsible. A prominent politician is said to have told a number of negroes from this county in Raleigh that Stephens was not the man to lead the party in Caswell, and that \u201che must be got rid of\u201d\u2026The inference is that Stephens was murdered to make political capital, and, like the disguised negroes in Alamance who were sent to the Penitentiary for perpetrating Ku Klux outrages while representing themselves to be white men, there are many who are satisfied that the late Senator Stephens was a victim of the political designs of the leaders of his own party.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fob97280\" id=\"viewer-fob97280\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Another account of the Stephens Murder, as published in the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0by \u201cA Citizen of Caswell,\u201d dubiously furthers the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Herald<\/span><\/em><span>\u2019s preposterous claim: \u201cI am confident from what has transpired since his death that his murder is quite as likely to have been the act of his own political partizans as of any other men\u2026I have no belief that he was killed by the Ku Klux, nor has any other person with whom I have conversed\u2026[T]he door of the room in which his body was found, was found to be bolted on the inside as well as locked. The perpetrators must have gone out at one of the windows, and these windows face a house occupied by colored people\u2026No white man could have gone in or out of one of these windows without being exposed to the almost certain detection of the occupants of the said house.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"e3hlm286\" id=\"viewer-e3hlm286\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The Caswell County coroner conducted an inquest that included testimony from numerous individuals, including Wiley and Lea, who lied about their knowledge of the affair. Sheriff Jesse Griffith\u2014a reputed Klansman\u2014also made little effort to pursue a thorough investigation. Without any substantive evidence, the coroner&#8217;s report issued a perfunctory verdict, that Stephens &#8220;came to his death by the hands of persons unknown to the jury.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"8ofl9288\" id=\"viewer-8ofl9288\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (41:12) \u2013 \u2018And we\u2019re in no interest of figuring out who, and we\u2019re not going to try, so just\u2026case closed. Leave us alone.\u2019 That\u2019s not justice. That\u2019s\u2014I don\u2019t know what that is\u2014that\u2019s state-sanctioned murder at that point, in my opinion, but\u2026I don\u2019t know.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"amy7g290\" id=\"viewer-amy7g290\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (41:31) \u2013 Yeah, well, like I said earlier, these local authorities\u2014they were either intimidated by or colluded with the Klan. And in this case, they certainly colluded.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fv6we293\" id=\"viewer-fv6we293\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (41:42) \u2013 On May 25, Holden publicly condemned Stephens\u2019s assassination and offered a $500 reward for information leading to the arrest of those responsible. He also wired U.S. Senator John Pool, requesting federal assistance. Six days later, Congress passed the Enforcement Act of 1870, which authorized the president and other federal officials to deploy the U.S. Army against the Klan. However, in this instance, President Grant chose not to employ it, since imposing the law ex post facto meant that none of its provisions could be used to address Stephen\u2019s murder.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"pkiul295\" id=\"viewer-pkiul295\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>For months, Governor Holden hesitated to deploy the militia against suspected Klan members, fully aware of the political backlash such a move would provoke. He had assumed that North Carolinians would condemn Klan atrocities and that President Grant\u2019s administration would offer tangible support, but neither materialized. The assassination of Senator Stephens, however, forced Holden\u2019s hand.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"a4vpj298\" id=\"viewer-a4vpj298\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On June 8, 1870, Holden met with Republican leaders in Raleigh to address the worsening crisis. Senator Pool pressed the governor to act decisively and proposed that any arrested Klansmen be tried by military tribunal. Richard Badger, one of Holden\u2019s closest advisers, cautioned against such measures and advocated for civil trials before a specially-appointed judge. Holden ultimately sided with Pool.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"zazbj300\" id=\"viewer-zazbj300\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Holden resolved to organize two militia regiments; their composition being of particular importance. Republican officials quickly dismissed the idea of relying on the regular state militia, convinced that too many of its members either sympathized with the Ku Klux Klan or could be easily intimidated by them.\u00a0Forming an all-black militia was not an option either. Holden understood that deploying armed, colored troops to arrest white suspects would almost certainly inflame racial unrest. Seeking reliable men, Holden turned to Republicans and Union veterans from western and eastern North Carolina.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fa85d304\" id=\"viewer-fa85d304\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Colonel William J. Clarke was chosen to command the first regiment, drawing recruits from the Piedmont and coastal plain communities. Clarke brought considerable military experience, having served as a captain in the Twelfth U.S. Infantry during the Mexican-American War and colonel of the 24<\/span><sup><span>th<\/span><\/sup><span>\u00a0North Carolina Regiment in the Civil War. He sustained a severe shoulder wound at the Battle of Drewry\u2019s Bluff in May 1864 and, after several months of recovery in Raleigh, returned to active duty in January 1865. Federal troops captured Clarke shortly thereafter in \u00a0Dinwiddie Courthouse in Virginia, and he spent the war\u2019s final months imprisoned at Fort Delaware.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"oiora308\" id=\"viewer-oiora308\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Although Clarke was an antebellum Democrat and Confederate veteran, he joined the Republican Party during Reconstruction and campaigned for Ulysses S. Grant and Schuyler Colfax during the 1868 presidential election.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"slmtl310\" id=\"viewer-slmtl310\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Upon hearing the news of Clarke\u2019s appointment, his sister-in-law, Sophia Devereux Turner\u2014the wife of <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0editor Josiah Turner Jr.\u2014wrote to him in disbelief: &#8220;I hear you are a Radical in other, and in plain terms a Scalawag\u2026You are determined to make [your wife and family] sufferers for what I will only believe is a political freak. Can You bear to think Your Darling Daughter shall be cut off in school&#8230;by the epithet Scalawag\u2019s Daughter[?]&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"0he9g317\" id=\"viewer-0he9g317\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (44:52) \u2013 I guess she didn\u2019t approve.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"89r3c319\" id=\"viewer-89r3c319\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (44:54) \u2013 No! Wow.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"l6f7i321\" id=\"viewer-l6f7i321\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (44:57) \u2013 And isn&#8217;t it crazy how she\u2019s Josiah Turner&#8217;s wife? Like, what are the odds?\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"uzh8p325\" id=\"viewer-uzh8p325\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (45:02) \u2013 Yeah! It\u2019s like\u2026it\u2019s such a small world, but within that small world, the layers and the paths that these people take\u2014unpredictable, to say the least.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"pbzi1327\" id=\"viewer-pbzi1327\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (45:14) \u2013 In a public speech, Clarke expressed his contempt for Klan violence: \u201cI honestly believe that we now have to decide the question of peace, or war. If I had not so thought, I [would have] remained in the quiet and seclusion of private life&#8230;I assure you, it requires a strong sense of duty to induce me to take an antagonistic position to many cherished friends\u2026and to expose myself to the torrent of [Conservative] invective and vituperation\u2026but a man whose patriotic instincts carried him into two wars, and who has participated in twenty battles, will probably have sufficient fortitude to risk the stings of wasps and hornets.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"r9ghs330\" id=\"viewer-r9ghs330\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Before the militia campaign began, Holden sent Clarke to Washington D.C. to &#8220;secure an outfit for the force.&#8221; In his absence, Colonel George Washington Kirk assumed field command.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"dr87b332\" id=\"viewer-dr87b332\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Early in the Civil War, Kirk was conscripted into the Confederate Army, but as an outspoken Unionist, he escaped and joined the federal ranks. Kirk gained a reputation as an adept scout and capable leader of the Second and Third North Carolina Mounted Infantry units, making frequent incursions into western North Carolina and guiding Southern Unionists and escaped prisoners-of-war to federally-occupied Kentucky.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"nmuzp334\" id=\"viewer-nmuzp334\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In June 1864, Kirk led 130 men from Knoxville to attack Camp Vance, situated near Morganton, North Carolina. Union General John M. Schofield credited Kirk\u2019s assault with inflicting significant damage on the Confederate war effort, reporting, &#8220;At Camp Vance, [Kirk] destroyed a large quantity of rebel property, including one locomotive&#8230;three cars, the depot and commissary buildings, 1,200 small-arms&#8230;[and] 300 bushels [of] grain&#8230;besides obtaining forty recruits for his regiment.\u201d\u00a0During the war\u2019s final months, Kirk participated in General George Stoneman&#8217;s raid into North Carolina and accepted the terms of surrender of William Holland Thomas&#8217;s Confederate Legion on May 9, 1865.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"nxwet338\" id=\"viewer-nxwet338\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In 1867, Kirk received a commission in the Tennessee militia. Two years later, he commanded a regiment that occupied Jackson and Overton counties, apprehending numerous Klansmen. By the time Kirk received Holden\u2019s appointment, he resided in Jonesborough, Tennessee.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ko92w340\" id=\"viewer-ko92w340\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Kirk&#8217;s reputation as a \u201cnotorious desperado\u201d\u2014rooted in his service as a former Union officer\u2014proved especially controversial. Conservatives fiercely opposed him, and a number of prominent Republicans expressed skepticism. William M. Moore of Yancey County cautioned Holden that Kirk &#8220;is very odious to a great many Citizens of this Country, and to some good Republicans. If troops Must be raised in the West, I hope you will at once revoke the Commission of Colonel Kirk and appoint&#8230;a Citizen of North Carolina.&#8221; Albert H. Dowell, a Republican from Asheville, thought Kirk would bring doom upon the Republican Party: &#8220;Such men as Colonel Kirk do not do a political party good. He is universally detested by the people as a military man\u2014they fear and hate him.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"d46l0342\" id=\"viewer-d46l0342\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>While some characterized Kirk as a derelict, others defended his record. The <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Rutherford Star<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0reprinted a letter from Horace H. Walpole\u2014the former colonel of the 122<\/span><sup><span>nd<\/span><\/sup><span>\u00a0New York Infantry Regiment\u2014who endorsed Kirk as\u00a0&#8220;the right character to mete out even-handed justice to those in his country who were Rebel guerrillas during the war, and who now largely compose the &#8216;Ku Klux.&#8217; Among the true blue Unionists of Western North Carolina and Eastern Tennessee, Colonel Kirk was their right handman, leader, and protector&#8230;in many instances he thoroughly whipped organized bodies of these Rebel outlaws&#8230;and was indeed a perfect terror to these miscreants, these enemies of mankind\u2026I think he is the right man in the place, and that our Northern Republicans ought to back him against the whole array of traducers and slanderers&#8230;we all ought to stand by this conspicuously gallant and efficient officer.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"bthc9348\" id=\"viewer-bthc9348\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Governor Holden hoped Kirk&#8217;s ties to the North Carolina mountains would help him recruit former Union troops and Republican sympathizers for the militia unit. Calls for volunteers echoed across the deepest hollows and highest peaks of western North Carolina. Hundreds of handbills were circulated and read aloud among mountain communities, declaring: &#8220;Rally union men in defense of your state! Your old commander has been commissioned to raise at once a regiment of state troops, to aid in enforcing the laws, and in putting down&#8230;the horrible murders and other atrocities committed by rebel K.K.K.&#8221; Kirk eventually raised a sizable force of approximately 670 men, the majority from western North Carolina, with several recruits from eastern Tennessee.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"2g74p351\" id=\"viewer-2g74p351\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>State leaders planned a three-phase operation: Clarke\u2019s regiment would garrison Raleigh, Kirk\u2019s men would occupy Alamance and Caswell counties to arrest suspected Klansmen, and both units would help secure polling stations during the August 4 election.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"2ta9c353\" id=\"viewer-2ta9c353\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>But conservative newspapers, like the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>, fearmongered the \u201cpersecuted\u201d public over the militia\u2019s deployment: \u201cINDIAN WARFARE \u2013 \u201cFor a life, another life. For a blow, another blow.\u201d Then the object of the new military movement is to initiate the well know Indian doctrine, namely, if an Indian is killed, some white man, no matter who, must be killed to appease his spirit. Is this what the Governor means? Who will he kill for Colgrove? Who will be murdered for Stephens? Who hung for Outlaw? The civil authorities either could not or would not detect and arrest those who committed these murders, and as we are to have \u201ca life for a life,\u201d we suppose somebody is to be picked up, perhaps on bare suspicion\u2026and hung and shot\u2026Kirk is imported to execute it. Ah! He is the man for the Governor!\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ju82e357\" id=\"viewer-ju82e357\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (50:46) \u2013 Well maybe if there was justice in the land, and the law enforcement was doing its job, they wouldn\u2019t need to raise up this force in the first place. I mean, death begets death, right? Like\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"grad7359\" id=\"viewer-grad7359\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (51:02) \u2013 In mid-July, the state militia assembled in Company Shops (present-day Burlington) and officially mustered into service. Clarke\u2019s coastal contingent constituted the First North Carolina Regiment, while Kirk\u2019s mountaineers formed the Second North Carolina Regiment. The newly organized troops were issued uniforms, equipment, and Springfield rifles.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"2iii0363\" id=\"viewer-2iii0363\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Conservative commentators disparaged Kirk\u2019s militia as backward, poverty-stricken, and obtuse. A July 30<\/span><sup><span>th<\/span><\/sup><span>\u00a0editorial in the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>New York Herald<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0claimed that the mountaineers &#8220;look upon their muskets with a great deal of curiosity (doubtlessly wondering what they are for) and a good deal of awe; and their feeble minds are constantly vibrating between fear of this novel and formidable weapon so suddenly committed to their hands, and an overpowering dread of the bloodthirsty Ku Klux. At the slightest alarm after sunset they huddle together like a flock of sheep.&#8221; Another <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Herald<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0correspondent wrote, \u201cA large majority of them [have] that sickly saffron colored complexion peculiar to the class known in the South as clay eaters&#8217;.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lxisk371\" id=\"viewer-lxisk371\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (52:06) \u2013 What? I don\u2019t even\u2014I don\u2019t think I\u2019ve heard of that. What?<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lpuoz373\" id=\"viewer-lpuoz373\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (52:10) \u2013 I guess it means that they&#8217;re so poor, they eat dirt, and their skin has taken on the color of the clay they consume.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"qh2l7377\" id=\"viewer-qh2l7377\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (52:16) \u2013 Oh, okay. Oh gosh. \u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"e45rn379\" id=\"viewer-e45rn379\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (52:20) \u2013 Kirk divided his forces\u2014assigning two hundred soldiers to Lieutenant Colonel George Bergen\u2014and hastened to Raleigh to confer with Holden. Relying on intelligence gathered from Republicans in Alamance and Caswell counties, as well as disillusioned Klan members, Holden supplied Kirk with a list of individuals to arrest.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"01an9381\" id=\"viewer-01an9381\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On July 13, Holden authorized Kirk to &#8220;take the necessary steps to preserve order, and to give the fullest protection to life and property.&#8221; The militia was directed to &#8220;take charge of the public buildings [in Alamance and Caswell counties], and arrest and hold for examination persons accused of felonies, especially those charged with, or being accessory to, the murder of J.W. Stephens and Wyatt Outlaw.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"6njsn383\" id=\"viewer-6njsn383\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (53:03) \u2013 I&#8217;d also like to point out a neat parallel. Going back to our first episode on the Fishing Creek Confederacy, Union soldiers were supplied a list of names\u2014provided by either Republican officials or party sympathizers\u2014and they arrested people based on that list. Now, obviously that took place during the Civil War, where habeas corpus was suspended and martial law was in place. But at this point, North Carolina is no longer under military rule.\u00a0They&#8217;ve been readmitted into the Union. So now you have a situation\u2014and this is where the conflict comes into play\u2014where the governor is suspending habeas corpus extralegally during peacetime.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"m9meg386\" id=\"viewer-m9meg386\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (53:43) \u2013 Yeah, I mean, it\u2019s fascinating when you think about expediency, and what politicians and governments sometimes will do. I mean, to bind us together as a society, we would need to think that those words are resolute, and that they are\u2014almost like structures, in the sense of they exist independent of us. You know, they are words that we\u2014they are principles that we base our\u2026At the end of the day, though, all countries, societies, organizations, everything\u2014they\u2019re just people. And it\u2019s like, the words on the page\u2014the only meaning that they have is what the people give it to them. And, as you just said, the Civil War isn\u2019t happening anymore, and the Constitution lays out certain processes that are just\u2014for expediency\u2019s sake\u2014being, you know\u2026The flexibility is important, but it\u2019s always a balancing act.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wysw9388\" id=\"viewer-wysw9388\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (54:44) \u2013 Upon arriving in Yanceyville on July 18, Kirk learned that congressional candidates James Madison Leach and William L. Scott were holding a public debate at the Caswell County courthouse. Kirk\u2019s force, about 350 men, surrounded the building and arrested several suspects, including Leach, though he was later released.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"7bd8a391\" id=\"viewer-7bd8a391\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Hillsborough Recorder<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0described the scene: \u201cKirk\u2019s troops arrived in the suburbs of Yanceyville Monday evening about two o\u2019clock. There was [a] going on in the courthouse, a political meeting\u2014a discussion between Leach and Scott. Kirk waited outside of the town till the courthouse was filled and the speaking had begun. Then he marched in and deployed his men in and around the room. The door was closed. And then Kirk made the first arrest. Going up to Sheriff Griffith, who stood in the vestibule, with a pistol cocked in his hand, he laid his hand on him and said, \u201cyou are my prisoner.\u201d\u00a0Griffith asked, \u201cBy what authority?\u201d \u201cYonder is my authority,\u201d replied Kirk pointing\u2026to his armed men. The courthouse was kept closed for several hours and the balance of the arrests made in good order.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"mruh1397\" id=\"viewer-mruh1397\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (55:47) \u2013 \u201cYonder is my authority,\u201d yeah. He\u2019s just keeping it real, I guess.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ujeo1399\" id=\"viewer-ujeo1399\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (55:53) \u2013 That\u2019s such a great line: \u2018Yonder.\u2019\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"mf889401\" id=\"viewer-mf889401\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (55:56) \u2013 \u201cYonder,\u201d and you just point, and you see\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"amzua403\" id=\"viewer-amzua403\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (55:59) \u2013 Just point and you see, like, three hundred armed men just around the courthouse and you\u2019re like \u2018Ahh. Oh no.\u2019<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"gdvhs405\" id=\"viewer-gdvhs405\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (56:03) \u2013 That is an epic line. That is an epic\u2014they could make that in a movie or something, just saying \u2018On whose authority?\u2019 \u2018Yonder.\u2019 I love the word yonder. That\u2019s a\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wzyws407\" id=\"viewer-wzyws407\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (56:14) \u2013 Well, bring back Smelfungus. Bring back yonder.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wxbev409\" id=\"viewer-wxbev409\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (56:17) \u2013 Smelfungus and yonder, let\u2019s go! I like it.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"8o806411\" id=\"viewer-8o806411\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (56:25) \u2013 \u201cThe excitement\u2026[grows] more intense each day,\u201d declared the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>New York Herald<\/span><\/em><span>. \u201cBy instructions from Colonel Kirk, commanding the East Tennessee jay-hawkers and free-booters, no person is admitted to see the prisoners, and\u2026some of them may be tried and convicted on irresponsible testimony by a court of Kirk\u2019s ignorant, illiterate and partisan officers, and perhaps executed by his hand.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"rj2r7416\" id=\"viewer-rj2r7416\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>General Grant has said that he had been informed that no man\u2019s life was safe in Caswell, that citizens were shot down in the streets, on the highways, and that the civil authorities countenanced all these outrages. Now in contradiction of these reports, I have the assurance of two officers in the United States army, now there, that they never knew a more law-abiding or more peaceably disposed community before in their lives.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ym0dh418\" id=\"viewer-ym0dh418\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In total, 101 men were arrested on suspicion of Klan-related activity. Among those detained were former U.S. Congressman John Kerr Jr. and the sheriffs of Alamance and Caswell counties. No one was killed during the militia campaign and Klan activity promptly ceased. Nevertheless, the show of force sparked significant public outrage. \u201cAlamance and Caswell counties have been invaded by armed minions of North Carolina\u2019s new-fledged tyrant,\u201d lamented the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Wilmington Journal<\/span><\/em><span>, \u201cthe liberty of their citizens has been disregarded, and the habeas corpus spit upon.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"05ks7422\" id=\"viewer-05ks7422\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Almost immediately after their arrests, the suspected Klansmen petitioned Chief Justice Richmond Mumford Pearson of the North Carolina Supreme Court for writs of habeas corpus. Among those seeking relief was Adolphus Moore, the alleged organizer of Wyatt Outlaw\u2019s murder.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"6a2cg424\" id=\"viewer-6a2cg424\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Chief Justice Pearson was a Republican and largely sympathetic with Holden&#8217;s efforts; however, he determined that state militia\u2019s arrests constituted unlawful detention. He consequently issued writs of habeas corpus, mandating that the accused appear before a civil court rather than a military tribunal.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"krqz8426\" id=\"viewer-krqz8426\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On July 18, Pearson\u2019s writs were returned unserved. According to the attached affidavit, Colonel Kirk dismissed the writs as \u201cplayed out\u201d and would only surrender the prisoners by Governor Holden\u2019s command.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"nj0rf428\" id=\"viewer-nj0rf428\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Pearson wrote to Holden: \u201cSir: I have the honor to enclose copies of four writs of habeas corpus\u2014issued to me by Colonel George W. Kirk\u2014together with affidavits, setting out that Colonel Kirk refused to make returns of the writs, and state that he made the arrests by your order. As Colonel Kirk does not make return, I do not feel at liberty to assume the fact that he acted under your orders, from the conversation set out in the affidavits. Please inform me if Colonel Kirk acted under order from you in making the arrests.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"spkmr430\" id=\"viewer-spkmr430\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Holden replied: \u201c[Colonel Kirk] was instructed firmly but respectfully to decline to deliver the prisoners [under my orders]. No one goes before one in respect for the civil law, or those whose duty it is to enforce it, but [given] the condition of Alamance County, and some other parts of the State\u2026I have been forced to declare them in a state of insurrection\u2026At this time, I am satisfied that the public interest required that these military prisoners shall not be delivered up to the civil power.\u201c<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"c3x1a432\" id=\"viewer-c3x1a432\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The governor further contended that \u201cthe Constitution and laws of the United States and of this State are set at naught; the civil courts are no longer a protection to life, liberty and property; assassination and outrage go unpunished, and the civil magistrates are intimidated and are afraid to perform their functions\u2026thus, civil government [is] crumbling around me.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"sl41r434\" id=\"viewer-sl41r434\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Holden\u2019s letters were presented before the State Supreme Court. Since Holden and Kirk openly defied Pearson\u2019s order, the petitioners\u2019 counsel moved for a writ of attachment, seeking to arrest both men for contempt.\u00a0They also requested that the Chief Justice immediately assume custody of the militia\u2019s detainees, since Kirk had failed to show \u201csufficient excuse for his neglect and refusal\u201d to comply with habeas corpus.\u00a0The fact that he acted under the Governor\u2019s direction was irrelevant; Kirk \u201chad the prisoners in his custody, and he is the proper person to whom the writ should have been directed, and he must obey it by making a proper return to it.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"rf6o5436\" id=\"viewer-rf6o5436\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Chief Justice Pearson delivered his opinion on this contentious legal quandary\u2014Ex parte Moore\u2014on July 23, 1870. While Pearson acknowledged Holden\u2019s authority to declare a county in a state of insurrection, he could not suspend habeas corpus or subject civilians to trial by military commission. As Pearson wrote, \u201cThe means must be proper, as well as necessary, and the detention of a petitioner as a military prisoner is not a proper means, for it violates the Declaration of Rights.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"88ld9439\" id=\"viewer-88ld9439\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>However, even though Holden exceeded his gubernatorial authority, Pearson determined that Colonel Kirk could not be forced to return the prisoners to civil court, since he was following Holden\u2019s direct orders. As North Carolina\u2019s commander-in-chief, the governor exercised the physical power of the state, while the judiciary possessed only moral authority. Drawing on political theory, Pearson reasoned that two branches of government could not oppose each other. Therefore, he lacked the power to authorize the governor\u2019s arrest, let alone compel the prisoners\u2019 release. Enforcement of the writs ultimately fell to Governor Holden\u2019s discretion.\u00a0\u201cI have discharged my duty,\u201d Pearson said. \u201c[T]he power of the Judiciary is exhausted, and the responsibility must rest on the Executive\u2026Having conceded full faith and credit to the action of his Excellency, within the scope of the power conferred [to] him, I feel assured he will in like manner give due observance to the law as announced by the judiciary.\u201d Unsurprisingly, Holden refused to abide by the writs.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"62980443\" id=\"viewer-62980443\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:01:48) \u2013 So I\u2019m interested to hear your take, since you\u2019re in law\u2014you are a lawyer. What do you think of that argument?<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"k8xpe445\" id=\"viewer-k8xpe445\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:01:55) \u2013 I mean\u2014so it\u2019s a state law issue, and it would depend on, like, what the\u2014I think it\u2019s a copout, if I\u2019m being honest. I think the way that our government is supposed to work, right, is we have the Constitution\u2026the President\u2014the executive, legislative, and judicial bodies are supposed to\u2026all their efforts, all their guiding principles are supposed to be tailored towards the Constitution\u2014like, the President\u2019s Oath of Office is to swear to uphold and defend the Constitution. The Constitution lays out how things are supposed to happen.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"q7815447\" id=\"viewer-q7815447\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>I think what often you\u2019ll find there\u2026basically in almost every state, the judiciary is very reluctant to overstep\u2014or to tell the executive branch that they can\u2019t do things\u2014because it\u2019s easy to view them less legitimately than you would Congress or the executive branch because citizens aren\u2019t typically voting directly on the judges. I know like in Wisconsin, or maybe it was Minnesota, they\u2014citizens do vote on their judges. But if I had to guess why, it would probably be that the judges were afraid of, you know, questioning an elected official in that kind of a way. And it goes back to the whole, like\u2026Sure, there\u2019s words on a page and the Constitution tells you to do something, but if someone has the backing and the power of \u2018yonder,\u2019 you know? They\u2019re going to\u2014people will bend.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"h54gj449\" id=\"viewer-h54gj449\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>You shouldn\u2019t let fear prevent you from upholding the Constitution. If they decided that, like\u2014there could be pedantic procedural arguments as to the legitimacy of the\u2026but just overall, like <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Marbury v. Madison<\/span><\/em><span>, basically the Supreme Court is supposed to interpret whether the actions of the executive branch and the legislative branch abide by the Constitution. And if they don\u2019t, that\u2019s like the whole\u2014the court\u2019s whole job is to say: \u2018Uh-uh, that\u2019s not the Constitution.\u2019 But if they just do the, \u2018We\u2019re not even going to weigh in because, you know, it\u2019s their domain\u2019\u2014if that\u2019s what the Constitution says, then okay, but if they\u2019re just saying that because they want no part of it, and no matter what they\u2019re going to try to say, they\u2019re just being cowards\u2014that\u2019s a problem. That\u2019s when everything starts to break down.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"r2d1n453\" id=\"viewer-r2d1n453\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>So, it depends, you know? And a lot of people will hide their cowardice behind overscrupulous, little pedantic procedural arguments. It\u2019s like you can\u2019t lose sight of why you\u2019re there. You\u2019re there to protect the Constitution. You\u2019re there to\u2014I hope\u2014try to make the world a better place. You\u2019re not there to just decide the easy stuff and then when it gets hard, back away. Like, that\u2019s my opinion. I\u2019m sure if you were to analyze the, like, the case or the\u2026So, do you know\u2014did they\u2014was it just like a judicial decision? Was it like a\u2014like that source, or\u2014basically what the judges said?<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ejwls455\" id=\"viewer-ejwls455\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:05:00) \u2013 So, Pearson was the Chief Justice of the North Carolina Supreme Court, and I believe he made this decision unilaterally\u2014like, there was no judicial panel involved, or anything like that.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"e0900458\" id=\"viewer-e0900458\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:05:12) \u2013 Yeah, and sometimes there\u2019ll be like a\u2014like, you\u2019ll notice in today\u2019s government\u2014there\u2019s a lot of shadow docket decisions, or whatever, where you know, the Supreme Court will try to, like, just decide something without issuing an opinion\u2014in the middle of the night, or whatever, and like\u2014usually they\u2019re not supposed to be doing that that much. It\u2019s supposed to be for, like, emergencies. They\u2019ve been doing that a lot more lately. I\u2019m interested, like, if you were to get into the weeds of why his opinion was that way, then I\u2019d be like \u2018maybe he has a good argument, maybe not\u2019\u2014but regardless, something of that magnitude, I think you owe it to the people of your state\u2026and to the government\u2014the Constitution itself\u2014to give a little more, or to like\u2026I don\u2019t know.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"iokap460\" id=\"viewer-iokap460\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:05:56) \u2013 Yeah, I think it all boils down to, you know, the system of checks and balance, right? Like, you see it at the federal level. It\u2019s the same at the state level. You know, I think the point of the judiciary\u2014as you said\u2014is, like, to hold the other two branches accountable. In this case, you know\u2014however noble the cause was\u2014Holden clearly overstepped his authority as governor. So that\u2014that\u2019s when the judiciary should step in and be like, \u2018No, this is what the constitution says and what you\u2019re doing is illegal.\u2019 And in a way, he does come out and say that\u2014he does say, like, he can\u2019t suspend habeas corpus\u2014but then he then breaks it down and says, \u2018well, I only possess the moral authority, so the actual\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"zwf89462\" id=\"viewer-zwf89462\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:06:35) \u2013 Yeah.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"71uha464\" id=\"viewer-71uha464\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:06:36) \u2013 \u2026the actual interpretation of the constitution is imposed to the governor and what his morals are.\u2019<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"3wc8c466\" id=\"viewer-3wc8c466\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:06:45) \u2013 And that\u2019s so, in my opinion, that\u2019s so wrong. That\u2019s like so\u2026Basically, you know what the big\u2014like in\u2026peel back all the robes and the words, and\u2014it\u2019s basically, \u2018What you\u2019re doing isn\u2019t right. My job is to tell you it\u2019s not right. I have no \u2018yonder\u2019 to back me up. I can\u2019t stop you.\u2019 That\u2019s really what it like\u2014I mean, I could phrase it. I could give a very\u2014a sixty-page legal treatise with all the citations and whatever\u2014but like, when you really boil it down, that\u2019s the problem. That\u2019s always been the judiciary\u2019s problem is that\u2014or not problem, I shouldn\u2019t say problem, but just their\u2014and they shouldn\u2019t. I mean, if you gave judges the same kinds of military forces that you gave the President and the\u2014the problem with the judges is the reason they don\u2019t have that is because they\u2019re not elected. Could you imagine if like, there\u2019s, you know, twelve judges who just ran the military and they were answerable to no one? Like we, you know\u2026it can go the wrong way, too.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fqpn4468\" id=\"viewer-fqpn4468\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>It\u2019s basically like, if they\u2019re not being elected by people, we don\u2019t want to give them that. And so then, it\u2019s this unspoken compact that\u2026okay, well if the judges are supposed to be extremely qualified, they\u2019re supposed to be extremely honorable, they\u2019re supposed to know the law\u2014the Constitution\u2014and if you do something and they tell you, \u2018don\u2019t do it,\u2019 you\u2019re not supposed to do it. And if you just start saying, \u2018I\u2019m not\u2014I\u2019m going to do it anyway. Stop me.\u2019 That\u2019s when we get into the constitutional crisis of like, well, what can the judiciary do if the executive branch pulls that card, right? If they do the \u2018Okay, you told me I can\u2019t do this. I\u2019m going to do it anyway.\u2019 \u00a0And then it\u2019s like\u2014then the judges have to try to say \u2018well\u2026\u2019 Because the moment they say, \u2018nope, what you did is wrong,\u2019 then it becomes \u2018well stop me.\u2019 And if they can\u2019t stop them, then they lose all sense of legitimacy because then it\u2019s like, \u2018well why do we listen to them in the first place?\u2019 And it\u2019s just like a function\u2014our functioning constitutional republic. That\u2019s how it\u2019s supposed to work. But if you call the judiciary\u2019s bluff, if you will\u2026I mean, leave it to better minds than myself, but maybe there\u2019s something to be said for putting more faith in the judiciary. But at the same time, there have been countless judges or\u2014you know, like [the] Dred Scott decision. I think that\u2019s one of the worst\u2014I think I talked about that, whether it was the first episode or the second episode\u2014it\u2019s just one of the worst decisions I think in American history. And it\u2019s like, well\u2026it\u2019s just frustrating, right? Because you can see they can\u2019t say, \u2018Well what you\u2019re doing is wrong. You need to stop.\u2019 And then the executive branch saying, \u2018Well I\u2019m not going to. Stop me.\u2019 And it\u2019s like\u2026I\u2019m kind of rambling, but it\u2019s like interesting to talk through it because you end up finding the truth of it.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"tqz76470\" id=\"viewer-tqz76470\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>And what I will say, too, though, is you know, their job\u2014they\u2019ve studied the Constitution their whole life. They\u2019ve studied case law, they\u2019ve studied the law, they\u2014every argument, they\u2019ve probably heard it, probably argued about it. And so, there\u2019s some level of deference that I think is warranted because not everybody is able or has the time to learn the Constitution and the law the way that they can. It\u2019s like in a healthy system, we all have to be bound by just some sense of trust in each other, and some sense of respect. And if we start\u2026it sounds trite\u2014it sounds like something you\u2019re taught as a kindergartener, or whatever\u2014but there is extreme value in it.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fsqju472\" id=\"viewer-fsqju472\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Sorry that was such a massive ramble. I love these\u2014I love the law stuff, though. And like constitutional law, whether it\u2019s federal or your own state\u2019s constitution, it\u2019s basically like\u2014it\u2019s the levers and wires that make this system run. It\u2019s fascinating.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"rpgbq474\" id=\"viewer-rpgbq474\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:10:41) \u2013 The <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Tarboro Southerner<\/span><\/em><span> strongly condemned the court\u2019s decision: \u201cJudge Pearson\u2014This individual, once esteemed so high for his legal learning, having been gradually sinking down to the depths of political infamy, has at last reached the bottom.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"5mnky479\" id=\"viewer-5mnky479\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>He has become the willing tool of W.W. Holden!<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"r4mhv481\" id=\"viewer-r4mhv481\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Great heavens! What a despicable position to be occupied by the Chief Justice of North Carolina!<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"e51bn483\" id=\"viewer-e51bn483\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>While declaring\u2026that Holden had no power to suspend the writ of habeas corpus, he yet, cowardly or with criminal connivance, refuses to compel him to give up his prisoners so unjustly detained.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"jw4td485\" id=\"viewer-jw4td485\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The acme of his infamy is reached when he says: \u201cThe power of the Judiciary is exhausted. I have no posse comitatus\u201d\u2014the veriest subterfuge to escape the responsibility of his high position.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"r2ypb487\" id=\"viewer-r2ypb487\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>He has certainly worked well for his radical master, the Governor, and will no doubt reap his reward\u2026in the contempt and hatred of a persecuted people, to whom they turned as their last hope in the day of trial, with the same result as the lamb going to the wolf for protection.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"5p7qt489\" id=\"viewer-5p7qt489\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:11:41) \u2013You know, it\u2019s a\u2014I think\u2026It\u2019s one of those, like a\u2014the critique. You follow the substance of the critique and then you can say, \u2018well maybe these people\u2014maybe it was like\u2026\u2019 We could argue morally about whether it was good or bad\u2014the [habeas corpus]\u2014but like, the judicial responsibility? I understand the critique. Like basically saying, \u2018You can\u2019t do that. I\u2019m so sure you can\u2019t do that. But I\u2019ve done everything I can and there\u2019s nothing more I can do.\u2019 It\u2019s just basically then you\u2019re put\u2014you know who you\u2019re putting it on, then? The voters. You\u2019re putting it on the people. They have to rise up and if they want the law to be followed\u2014and it\u2019s just like, you know, people like leadership and\u2026I don\u2019t know. It\u2019s tough. It\u2019s tough.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fal5z491\" id=\"viewer-fal5z491\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:12:28) \u2013 While the principle of habeas corpus languished in court, frustrations boiled over in Raleigh. Around midnight on July 22, an unknown number of assailants fired upon a colored encampment belonging to the First North Carolina State Troops. The camp\u2019s sentries returned fire, but no one was hurt.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"8ox54493\" id=\"viewer-8ox54493\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>While the incident itself proved rather inconsequential, the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0<\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span> used the episode to admonish the militia\u2019s incompetence: \u201cSome of the negro soldiers encamped at the Old Baptist Grove became alarmed at something last night, and commenced firing their guns at random in every direction\u2026it is said that the reason given for this conduct is, that some person or persons fired into their camp. We do not believe a word of this.\u201d The editorial went on and sarcastically charged that the perpetrator &#8220;was some jealous colored city civilian, taking revenge for the progress the black boys in blue are making among the colored damsels, causing them to snub the plain [clothed] chaps most provokingly.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"bjs8c500\" id=\"viewer-bjs8c500\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:13:25) \u2013 Just pit them all against each other, and\u2026yeah, it\u2019s divide and conquer. It\u2019s the tool that racists have used since the beginning of time. Like, ugh. That\u2019s just\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"3agbg502\" id=\"viewer-3agbg502\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:13:40) \u2013 Fearing potential retaliatory Klan violence, Holden again requested federal reinforcements. President Grant responded by deploying six companies of infantry\u2014approximately seven hundred soldiers\u2014to North Carolina.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"s3ghc504\" id=\"viewer-s3ghc504\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The tepid federal support aroused conservative disdain. As the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Lincoln County Herald<\/span><\/em><span> of Missouri observed: \u201cThe rascally Governor Holden of North Carolina, and his sub-rascal Kirk, now have one hundred men under arrest, with the habeas corpus annihilated. They have refused to surrender to Chief Justice Pearson these outraged citizens; and to help out this woeful crime, the block head in the white house\u2026backs the scoundrels who are destroying peace and government in North Carolina.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ho33o508\" id=\"viewer-ho33o508\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Now we can\u2019t forget that, amidst all this turmoil, North Carolina was preparing for its state elections, scheduled for August 4, 1870. The timing of Governor Holden\u2019s militia campaign convinced many Conservatives that its true purpose was to intimidate voters and forcibly uphold Radical Republicanism.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"gf27k510\" id=\"viewer-gf27k510\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>One such detractor, William A. Hearne, penned the following editorial in the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Tarboro North Carolinian<\/span><\/em><span>: \u201c[I]n days of old, when a ruler of the people prostituted his position to wicked purposes of oppression, and so basely betrayed his public trust as the Governor of North Carolina has, so frequently done for partisan purposes, the swords of patriots leaped from their scabbards, THE KNIFE OF THE ASSASSIN FELT UNEASILY, BUT SURELY, FOR THE HEART OF THE RUFFIAN RULER.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"em70t514\" id=\"viewer-em70t514\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Even some Republican publications, like <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>The Washington Star<\/span><\/em><span>, reprimanded Holden for doing irreparable harm to the Republican Party: \u201cWe cannot resist the conviction that Governor Holden is pursuing a wholly mischievous and indefensible course in North Carolina. Giving all possible consideration to the asseverations of Governor Holden in regard to the Ku Klux Klan outrages and resistance to law, we see nothing to justify his violent despotic acts\u2026[T]he extreme measures he has resorted to are dictated solely by a reckless, unscrupulous determination to carry out his own political ends at all hazards\u2026The deeds of greedy, unscrupulous men, like Holden\u2026are doing infinite mischief to the Republican cause, making it impossible to build up a self-sustaining Republican party in the South\u2026[Holden] is simply a demagogue trickster and political desperado. A blatant secessionist when secession was uppermost, he is just the style of man now to persecute with rabid vindictiveness not only his secession neighbors, but all republicans who oppose his oppressive reign.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"h20ls518\" id=\"viewer-h20ls518\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:16:08) \u2013 And they kind of have a point. Holden did ultimately vote for secession and his track record with policymaking is spotty at best.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"x290d521\" id=\"viewer-x290d521\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:16:16) \u2013 You know, I will say, you try to\u2014if you think about the common thread\u2026you know, obviously I\u2014the Ku Klux Klan is terrible. They need to be stopped. I completely\u2026It\u2019s really hard to\u2014I mean, there\u2019s no argument really there, but clearly there\u2019s some political motivation, and it seems like the common thread throughout all his\u2026It does seem like there, as you said, there\u2019s an argument that the one consistent thread in his political career has been opportunism, or whatever. So I get it.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"9ops3523\" id=\"viewer-9ops3523\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:16:50) \u2013 With militiamen stationed at the polls, North Carolina\u2019s 1870 elections proceeded with surprising civility. Even imprisoned Klansmen were permitted to submit their votes.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ue20s526\" id=\"viewer-ue20s526\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:17:00) \u2013 I was just going to say, so imprisoned Klansmen can vote\u2026were African Americans have the right to vote or, you know, I guess they did, but I wonder\u2014you know, it\u2019s just like the [hypocrisy] or whatever\u2014there\u2019s all these people saying they shouldn\u2019t have the right to vote, but meanwhile imprisoned Klansmen are being given the right to vote. Like, it\u2019s just\u2026I don\u2019t know.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"o31fo528\" id=\"viewer-o31fo528\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:17:24) \u2013 Republican leaders approached the race with confidence, anticipating a repeat of their 1868 victory. But the final results defied their expectations. Conservative candidates captured a decisive majority in the General Assembly and claimed the state attorney general\u2019s office, while Republican support plummeted by nearly 13,000 votes. \u201cHolden and his crew went up like a rocket and have come down like a stick,\u201d scoffed the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Weekly Clarion<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0of Jackson, Mississippi. \u201c[T]hey have fallen, never to rise again.\u201d\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"jtboa532\" id=\"viewer-jtboa532\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The election essentially became a referendum on what the Democratic press dubbed as the \u201cKirk-Holden War\u201d\u2014a derisive term meant to accentuate Radical Republican tyranny and military despotism. Conservative critics frequently targeted Holden\u2019s use of public funds to finance the militia campaign. <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0editor Josiah Turner Jr. spearheaded these attacks, and estimated that the operation cost between $250,000 and $500,000. By spotlighting these expenditures\u2014at a time when many North Carolinians were still reeling from the economic consequences of the Civil War\u2014Conservative leaders successfully portrayed Republican policies as reckless and misguided.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"jmqac536\" id=\"viewer-jmqac536\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>To exemplify this intense partisanship, take the following exchange between the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Tarboro Southerner <\/span><\/em><span>and the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>New Bern Times<\/span><\/em><span>.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"t7xmj542\" id=\"viewer-t7xmj542\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Tarboro Southerner<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0originally reported: \u201cOur attention has been called to the engraving on the Republican ticket used in the recent election, representing a bale of cotton, with some mysterious letters marked on the head\u2026On being reversed, if we interpret them rightly, they spell the word WAR\u2026The question naturally suggests itself\u2014what does it mean? Is it a device of the [Loyal Leaguers] to prevent their members from voting any other ticket under the penalty of having war declared against them, or does it have any connection with the Holden-Kirk movement?\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"0o1we546\" id=\"viewer-0o1we546\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The<\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>\u00a0New Bern Times<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0replied: \u201cIt meant that the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Tarboro Southerner<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0was hard up for matter and selected the cotton bale as a subject, or we are in error. The \u201cwhat does it mean\u201d is a favorite dodge of the Democratic-Ku Klux organs, and has the merit of being entirely original with that style of press. It meant for us victory on a solid basis, but Ku Kluxism defeated us by putting fire in our cotton.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"gvm4j552\" id=\"viewer-gvm4j552\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>\u201cThe reply of the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Times<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0is simply contemptible,\u201d retorted the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Tarboro Southerner<\/span><\/em><span>. \u201cThe application of the term \u201cKu Klux organ\u201d to this paper is in keeping with the character of that scurrilous and mendacious sheet\u2026\u201cKu Klux\u201d indeed! That is all the argument you can get when you charge the thieves and swindlers with the crimes and outrages they have committed in North Carolina\u2026The solid basis he refers to is no doubt the military despotism of Holden and Kirk, which would [have indeed] been as solid as steel\u2014had the victory been achieved.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ah5br558\" id=\"viewer-ah5br558\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The assertion that the Radicals were defeated by Ku Kluxism is infamously false. The author of it is, in all probability, of the genus carpetbagger, a race of scape-graces mostly from Northern penitentiaries, who are prima facia characterless vagabonds\u2026Now that the election is over, and the spoils are no longer in reach of these vampires, many of them will gather up their wilted paper collars and their empty carpet bags, and go sneaking, like whipped spaniels [back home].\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"w4eg9560\" id=\"viewer-w4eg9560\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:20:30) \u2013 That\u2019s a good one. That\u2019s\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"eds9d562\" id=\"viewer-eds9d562\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:20:32) \u2013 What an exchange that was!<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"he50m564\" id=\"viewer-he50m564\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:20:34) \u2013 Yeah!<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"glrkf566\" id=\"viewer-glrkf566\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:20:38) \u2013 What began as an attempt to eradicate white supremacist violence quickly devolved into political disaster for Holden and North Carolina Republicans. Yet, the consequences of the Kirk-Holden War reverberated far beyond its immediate fallout.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"gzdg5568\" id=\"viewer-gzdg5568\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Shortly after midnight on August 8, Private George Bradley of the 4<\/span><sup><span>th<\/span><\/sup><span>\u00a0U.S. Artillery\u2014drunk and disoriented\u2014wandered toward the aforementioned black militia camp at Old Baptist Grove. The camp\u2019s sentry, Private John Pugh, spotted the interloper and twice ordered him to halt and identify himself. When Bradley ignored the warnings, Pugh shot him in the legs.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"1jy6i572\" id=\"viewer-1jy6i572\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Federal military officials were infuriated by the shooting. Post commandant Captain Royal T. Frank expressed disbelief that black militiamen, \u201cso utterly wanting in discretion and intelligence,\u201d had been entrusted with firearms. He demanded that civil authorities discipline Pugh and relocate the camp.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"qksfr576\" id=\"viewer-qksfr576\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>In a letter to General Henry Jackson Hunt, commander of federal troops in North Carolina, Colonel Clarke deplored the incident but defended Pugh\u2019s actions: &#8220;I deeply regret the unfortunate occurrence of last night\u2026My colored camp were fired on about three weeks since, and consequently they are very alert, and a man approaching the camp, at 1 o&#8217;clock at night and disregarding the challenge of the sentinel, was very naturally fired on.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"nwykp578\" id=\"viewer-nwykp578\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The following day, Raleigh\u2019s mayor acquitted Pugh of any wrongdoing. The militia camp was subsequently moved several blocks away.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"v7x4c580\" id=\"viewer-v7x4c580\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Aside from a few tense confrontations, the Kirk-Holden War remained relatively bloodless; however, that didn\u2019t stop Democratic newspapers from publishing reports that the militia tortured prisoners during interrogations. Upon learning of these disturbing allegations, Governor Holden immediately wrote to Kirk, emphasizing that any evidence gained through coercive means was &#8220;worthless. All prisoners, no matter how guilty they may be supposed to be, should be treated humanely.\u201d\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"5kdx6584\" id=\"viewer-5kdx6584\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Despite Holden\u2019s directives, not all officers played by the rules. On August 5, Lieutenant Colonel Bergen overstepped his authority by sending soldiers into Orange County\u2014an area not under martial law\u2014to apprehend <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0editor Josiah Turner Jr. Holden considered Turner a political antagonist who helped disseminate Klan propaganda. He was determined to detain Turner, but only if he entered Alamance of Caswell counties. Bergen ignored these limitations and unilaterally arrested Turner, who spent three weeks incarcerated in the Caswell County Courthouse.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"7dzcd590\" id=\"viewer-7dzcd590\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Bergen also attempted to extract confessions by stringing up several suspects in his charge. Conservative outlets, like the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Memphis Daily Appeal<\/span><\/em><span>, eagerly circulated these claims of militia misconduct:\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"lpxaw594\" id=\"viewer-lpxaw594\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>\u201cThe following is one of several affidavits made by Kirk\u2019s prisoners in regard to their treatment: Lucian H. Murray, being duly sworn, deposeth, and sayeth\u2026that on the 27<\/span><sup><span>th<\/span><\/sup><span>\u00a0of July last\u2026a guard of soldiers from the camp of G.W. Kirk\u2026had been [sent] to his place of business\u2026while he was absent therefrom. [Murray] went to the said camp and reported himself to one B.W. Bergen, who claimed to be Lieutenant Colonel under said Kirk\u2026Bergen immediately ordered [Murray] to be put under guard and detained\u2026as a prisoner.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"nzvuu598\" id=\"viewer-nzvuu598\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>[Bergen] then took [Murray] to his own tent, where there were three of his men armed with pistols; Bergen then said to this affiant that \u201che must tell him all about the hanging of Wyatt Outlaw.\u201d [Murray] replied that he knew nothing about it\u2026Bergen replied, \u201cIt is a damned lie; I know that you do\u201d\u2026Bergen put a rope around [Murray\u2019s neck] and said, \u201cPatten and Rogers (alluding to two other prisoners) knew nothing about it till they were hung up\u2026and you must do the same.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"8h9w2600\" id=\"viewer-8h9w2600\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>[H]aving already tied this affiant\u2019s arms in the manner usual with criminals about to be executed\u2026Bergen drew the rope, and swung [Murray] up by the neck. After suspending him for a short time, he was let down. Bergen asked him if he would confess then; [Murray] replied he had nothing to confess\u2026Bergen seized the rope and again hoisted [him] from the ground, more roughly than before and suspending him longer; upon being let down [Murray] was unable to speak for some time\u2026After other conversation and threats of killing\u2026Bergen said: \u201cI will now give you until tomorrow night, and if you don\u2019t confess then, I will kill you dead.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"iuih7602\" id=\"viewer-iuih7602\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Bergen\u2019s excesses eventually caught up to him. On August 26, Colonel Kirk ordered his arrest. Authorities detained him in Raleigh, where Company H of the 1<\/span><sup><span>st<\/span><\/sup><span> North Carolina State Troops held him under guard.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"b80vl606\" id=\"viewer-b80vl606\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Unable to find relief through the state courts, the suspected Klansmen petitioned Federal District Court Judge George W. Brooks for writs of habeas corpus. Brooks granted their requests and, in a blistering twenty-page opinion, condemned Governor Holden&#8217;s \u201crude soldiers\u201d for their \u201cbarbarous detention\u201d of suspects, which violated their due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment. He made no reference to the ongoing white supremacist violence that had initially prompted the arrests.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"tewdn608\" id=\"viewer-tewdn608\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:25:23) \u2013 That was going to be my one thing, is like I\u2014I have no idea what the, like, habeas corpus law is, right? But I guess the one time you suspend it is if law enforcement in the area that\u2019s supposed to be performing its duties aren\u2019t, because they\u2019re not detaining the people that need to be detained. And there\u2019s such riotous, like\u2014there\u2019s so much unlawfulness going on that you need to come in and\u2014and honestly, I mean, I don\u2019t know. If Ku Klux Klan, racial terror violence isn\u2019t enough, it\u2019s hard to like\u2014if that\u2019s not enough to justify it, I don\u2019t know what is. At the same time, what it really boils down to is just that law enforcement should have been doing their job on the local level. Then, you know, you wouldn\u2019t have to do all this, but you realize what happens if someone doesn\u2019t do their job\u2014someone isn\u2019t upholding the law, or upholding the Constitution\u2014it has a ripple effect. Not only down the food chain and how much it hurts the people\u2019s lives they\u2019re responsible to protect, but also up the food chain and, you know, how the authorities react and how the government works. And it\u2019s just like, just be honorable and do a good job. That\u2019s\u2014as scary as it might be\u2014you just got to try to do the right thing.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"kside610\" id=\"viewer-kside610\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:26:42) \u2013 And I think we&#8217;ve established, too, a pattern of violence that afflicted the North Carolina Piedmont in 1869, 1870. It was endemic.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wndcg613\" id=\"viewer-wndcg613\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:26:51) \u2013 Yeah.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"rficy615\" id=\"viewer-rficy615\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:26:52) \u2013 As we saw, the civil authorities, local magistrates\u2014they were either colluding with the Klan or just too intimidated by them. And that&#8217;s how we got to this point.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"xw6jm618\" id=\"viewer-xw6jm618\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:27:02) \u2013 Yep, yep. You know, it\u2019s funny. And I think it\u2019 easy to fall into the trap of \u2018oh, suspension of habeas corpus\u2014in and by itself\u2014[is a travesty].\u2019 I mean, how could you, you know? End of all\u2026If you look at the context of it, that\u2014that isn\u2019t one of those examples where I\u2019m like, completely unwarranted. No, that\u2019s one of those where I\u2019m like\u2014it\u2019s like one of those necessary evils, maybe? Like I don\u2019t know. But it\u2019s just that, as you said, like [a] systemic pattern. It\u2019s not just a\u2026it\u2019s all relative. It\u2019s all relative. But, yeah.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"1nw2z620\" id=\"viewer-1nw2z620\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:27:41) \u2013 On August 6, Brooks ordered Colonel Kirk to present the prisoners before him in Salisbury, North Carolina. Governor Holden was taken aback by the intervention, especially since federal courts typically lacked jurisdiction over state criminal matters. He immediately contacted President Grant to protest, declaring his intention to keep the prisoners detained unless otherwise compelled by federal troops. Holden sought to defy Judge Brooks as he had defied Judge Pearson, but Grant\u2014acting through Secretary of War Amos Ackerman\u2014instructed the governor to obey Brooks\u2019s writ. This directive placed Holden in a difficult position. Unable to openly defy the federal government, he acquiesced and ordered Kirk to turn the prisoners over to the civil courts.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"jq102622\" id=\"viewer-jq102622\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:28:22) \u2013 And it\u2019s like, with this scenario, you can\u2019t have your cake and eat it, too, right?<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"rdyhl625\" id=\"viewer-rdyhl625\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:28:26) \u2013 Yeah.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"w0l86627\" id=\"viewer-w0l86627\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:28:27) \u2013Early on, Holden was begging for intervention. He was telling the federal government, &#8216;Give me troops. Give me supplies. I need all the help I can get.&#8217; But now, when some federal judge does intervene but not in his favor, he&#8217;s like, &#8216;Whoa. Hold on a second. You can&#8217;t do that. This is a state matter.&#8217;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"gibyp630\" id=\"viewer-gibyp630\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:28:43) \u2013 A hundred percent. It\u2019s like, you got to be consistent, right? And what\u2019s the one thing that\u2019s been consistent for this guy? It\u2019s been his own, you know\u2014it\u2019s like\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"61hm5632\" id=\"viewer-61hm5632\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:28:50) \u2013 His own inconsistency!<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"goedq634\" id=\"viewer-goedq634\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:28:51) \u2013 Yeah. It\u2019s his own\u2014it\u2019s his own ambition\u2014it\u2019s his own\u2026and it\u2019s like, when you have people like that in charge, that\u2019s not good, you know? You got to be consistent, like you said. And it\u2019s like\u2014and you don\u2019t want to just be consistent to these weird, procedural ideas of like\u2014why don\u2019t we get back to being consistent about just like: Do unto others. Be good to your neighbor. Like\u2014like those\u2026you need some paradigm to understand and make judgments about the world. And you need to be consistent because the moment you lose that, then you start becoming this wish-washy, like\u2014Oh, well it\u2019s in my interest today. I like it. Oh, next week it\u2019s not, so now I don\u2019t. Like\u2014well how about, like\u2014my one consistent principle is I want to try to make people\u2019s lives better, not just my own, or whatever. But that, you know\u2026what\u2019s going to maximize the well-being of the most people?<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"dh39u636\" id=\"viewer-dh39u636\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:29:50) \u2013 The detainees were divided into two groups: one was brought before Judge Brooks in Salisbury, while the other appeared before Judge Pearson in Raleigh.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"hsmwc638\" id=\"viewer-hsmwc638\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The federal court hearings in Salisbury began on August 22. The prosecutorial team, led by outgoing Attorney General Lewis Olds\u2014Governor Holden\u2019s son-in-law\u2014 mistakenly assumed that the proceedings were only preliminary. Thus, they were unprepared and presented no evidence or witnesses that implicated the accused. Given the absence of probative evidence, Judge Brooks found that the charges lacked legal merit and immediately discharged the defendants.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"0btjp640\" id=\"viewer-0btjp640\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:30:23) \u2013 Kinda dropped the ball, there.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"wdfdd642\" id=\"viewer-wdfdd642\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:30:29) \u2013\u00a0The Raleigh hearings progressed somewhat better for the state. The prosecution presented enough evidence for Chief Justice Pearson to indict forty-nine prisoners, ordering them to be tried in the Alamance and Caswell County superior courts. However, none of those tried were convicted; all were acquitted and released by the end of August.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"1rjpp644\" id=\"viewer-1rjpp644\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The complete absence of convictions substantiated Governor Holden\u2019s claim that the civil courts were incapable of prosecuting the Klan. Whether through intimidation, collusion, or outright perjury, Klansmen ensured that their brethren would not be held accountable for their crimes.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"frbh5646\" id=\"viewer-frbh5646\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>\u201cThe civil law has proved powerless,\u201d lamented Joseph Holden, Governor Holden\u2019s son and editor of the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Raleigh Daily Standard<\/span><\/em><span>.\u00a0\u201cThis no one pretends to deny. What refuge for them, then? Nought save the strong arm of military power. None of us wish to resort to the last extremity, nor to be laid under the burden of taxes thus brought upon us. But above all consideration of dollars and cents is the life of the humblest citizen, and the poor and just of the community. All the trouble resulting from the use of the military be upon the heads of those who have provoked it and made it necessary.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"9el5p651\" id=\"viewer-9el5p651\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Governor Holden officially disbanded the militia on September 21, though he retained part of the 1<\/span><sup><span>st<\/span><\/sup><span>\u00a0North Carolina State Troops as personal bodyguards to prevent possible assassination attempts. On November 10, the proclamation of insurrection in Alamance and Caswell counties was lifted, officially ending the Kirk-Holden War.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"mq1ey657\" id=\"viewer-mq1ey657\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>As Democratic-Conservatives consolidated their governmental power, calls for Holden\u2019s impeachment intensified. The <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Tarboro Southerner<\/span><\/em><span>\u00a0rancorously exclaimed: \u201c[Governor Holden] is the vilest man that ever polluted a public office and his crimes are now crying in trumpet tones against him. Impeach the Traitor, the Apostate, and the Renegade, and drive him into the infamous oblivion which is so justly his due.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"jlujr661\" id=\"viewer-jlujr661\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On December 9, Orange County legislator Frederick N. Strudwick\u2014a known Klan organizer\u2014introduced eight articles of impeachment against Governor Holden in the North Carolina House of Representatives. All charges stemmed from Holden\u2019s use of extraordinary executive powers. The first two articles accused Holden of unlawfully declaring insurrection in Alamance and Caswell counties, alleging that he aimed to &#8220;stir up civil war, and subvert personal and public liberty, and the Constitution of said State.\u201d The remaining six items addressed various grievances, such as unlawful detention, the suspension of habeas corpus, and the improper use of state funds. Democratic legislators argued that Holden\u2019s militia campaign was not about suppressing Klan violence, but rather persecuting his political opponents and ensuring Republican dominance in the state government.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ug8xx665\" id=\"viewer-ug8xx665\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The House Judiciary Committee swiftly adopted Strudwick\u2019s resolution. On December 19, the House voted 60 to 46 in favor of impeachment. In response, members of the African American caucus issued a joint statement defending the governor, calling the impeachment proceedings retaliatory: \u201c[Governor Holden] thwarted the designs of a band of assassins, who had prepared to saturate this state in the blood of the poor people on the night before the last election, on account of their political sentiments, and to prevent them from voting.\u201d\u00a0The next day, Holden relinquished his governing authority to Lieutenant Governor Tod Robinson Caldwell.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"9cdvp670\" id=\"viewer-9cdvp670\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Prior to his impeachment trial, Holden publicly defended his actions:\u00a0\u201c[A]ll my appeals for law and order and peace\u2026were in vain. One of two courses was before me: Either to enforce the law with a strong hand, and thus make the fight of the sword, and not the use of it, as I did, the instrument for restoring civil power; or to resign my place and skulk from my oath and my duty into retirement. I could not do the latter, and hence I acted.\u00a0I have no doubt I made blunders and mistakes in some of the means which I employed to suppress the Ku Klux, but let me ask, did the Union and Confederate commanders make no mistakes in their operations during the late war?\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"k6p4u674\" id=\"viewer-k6p4u674\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:34:24) \u2013 Yeah, you know and I\u2014I just\u2026the Ku Klux Klan was so terrible, you know? It\u2019s\u2014I will give him credit for acknowledging, you know, \u201cI made blunders\u201d or whatever, but I have to agree in the sense of like\u2014the ultimate mission of stopping that terrorism\u2014like, you just\u2026tough decisions had to be made. You were going to\u2014you were either going to make people happy, make them sad, but\u2014I think, you know, you got to keep people safe from racial terror.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"vd70j676\" id=\"viewer-vd70j676\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:34:57) \u2013 Holden\u2019s impeachment trial ran from January 30 to March 22, 1871. Throughout the proceedings, prosecutors presented a steady stream of witnesses\u2014including several suspected Klan members from Alamance and Caswell counties\u2014who recounted abuses committed by Kirk\u2019s militiamen. One particular witness, Jesse Gant, characterized the militia as \u201ca parcel of vagabonds\u2026the most ignorant and stupid creatures I ever talked with, either white or black.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"j933c678\" id=\"viewer-j933c678\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Holdens defense lawyers challenged the credibility of Conservative witnesses, arguing that their political affiliations and Confederate ties tainted their testimonies. While the defense conceded that the militia\u2019s actions were far from ideal, subduing the Klan required extreme measures. Several defense witnesses described pervasive Klan activity, corroborating the argument for insurrection in Alamance and Caswell.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"4uof2680\" id=\"viewer-4uof2680\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Another area of contention involved the composition of Kirk\u2019s militia. Prosecutors claimed that many militia members were either too young, too old, or not residents of North Carolina, which violated the state\u2019s constitutional requirements: &#8220;All able-bodied male citizens of the State of North Carolina, between the ages of twenty-one and forty years, who are citizens of the United States, shall be liable to duty in the militia.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"l81gb682\" id=\"viewer-l81gb682\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>The defense countered that these statutory limitations only pertained to conscripted men, and \u201c[did] not apply\u2026to persons who volunteer [or] are willing to serve&#8230;whether the troops enlisted under Kirk were within or without the constitutional age, whether they were from Tennessee or North Carolina\u2014wherever they may have come\u2014when accepted by William Holden, they became and were part of the militia and could be used for any legitimate and proper service for which any other class of the militia could be used.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"ifo9f684\" id=\"viewer-ifo9f684\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Although tensions between Conservatives and Republicans ran high, courtroom decorum remained intact throughout the proceedings\u2014except on February 16, when Josiah Turner Jr. took the stand. As reported in the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Richmond Daily Dispatch<\/span><\/em><span>: \u201cHonorable Josiah Turner, editor of the <\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>Sentinel<\/span><\/em><span>, was examined [in court], and quite a scene took place. Turner, when asked in regard to the truth of Holden\u2019s allegations concerning him in his (Holden\u2019s) answer to the articles of impeachment, replied that they were as false as malice could make them. Holden arose nervously and looked as if he was going to speak, but took his seat without doing anything.\u00a0On being asked by respondent\u2019s counsel what were the relations between him and the respondent, he replied: \u201cSuch as could exist between a good and a bad man.\u201d Here the respondent arose, and said \u201che would not be insulted\u201d\u2026Holden then seized his hat and stalked out of the hall with a look of injured innocence.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"5nlw5692\" id=\"viewer-5nlw5692\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>William Smith, chief counsel for the defense, delivered his closing arguments by reiterating that Holden\u2019s actions fell squarely within the scope of state law and were solely motivated to protect the citizens of North Carolina. Lead prosecutor Thomas Bragg delivered with scathing rebuttal, contending that Holden had grossly exceeded his executive authority by imposing martial law, suspending habeas corpus, and authorizing the arrest of more than a hundred citizens without due process. He further argued that the militia campaign was both unnecessary and wasteful, resulting in the misuse of state funds and trampling of civil liberties. \u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"zsx8h694\" id=\"viewer-zsx8h694\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>On March 22, 1871, the North Carolina State Senate convicted Holden on six of eight impeachment charges\u2014 the first two articles received a simple majority, but fell short of the required two-thirds threshold for conviction. The Senate subsequently passed a resolution that deposed Holden as governor and prohibited him from holding public office in North Carolina ever again. With the Legislature\u2019s decision, Holden became the first governor in United States history to be removed through impeachment.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"2nntn700\" id=\"viewer-2nntn700\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:38:33) \u2013 So that whole campaign really backfired\u2026<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"gkvuv704\" id=\"viewer-gkvuv704\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:38:39) \u2013 \u2026in a way you would not expect.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"cp3rg706\" id=\"viewer-cp3rg706\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:38:40) \u2013 No, that\u2019s crazy. That is a crazy end to that saga, like\u2026wow. Wow.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"uoc7z708\" id=\"viewer-uoc7z708\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:38:52) \u2013 In August 1872, interim governor Caldwell faced off against Conservative Judge Augustus S. Merrimon during that year\u2019s gubernatorial election. Bolstered by their sweeping success in 1870, Democrats were confident of another victory. As one conservative pundit proclaimed, &#8220;Caldwell is the easiest to beat of any man in their party in the State\u2026To the rash spirit of Holden, he adds the sourness of a cynic and the inflexibility of a steel bar.\u201d<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"4iu6t710\" id=\"viewer-4iu6t710\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>However, Caldwell managed to eke out a narrow victory, winning by fewer than 2,000 votes out of nearly 200,000 cast. Merrimon\u2019s supporters tried to contest the outcome, but the Republican press reacted vigorously: \u201cWe care not what action the Legislature may take in the matter, the Republicans will resist any attempt to seat Judge Merrimon,\u201d proclaimed the G<\/span><em style=\"font-style:italic\"><span>reensboro Patriot<\/span><\/em><span>. \u201cWe are satisfied that Caldwell received a majority of the legal votes cast, and we hope he will maintain his rights in the premises, by moderate means at first\u2014at the point of the bayonet, if necessary\u2014Republicans will not submit to be Ku Kluxed out of their victory.\u201d The election results were ultimately accepted; however, this was the last time a Republican candidate won an outright majority until 1972.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"j3nl2717\" id=\"viewer-j3nl2717\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>GRANT (1:40:04) \u2013 After the Civil Rights Act. That\u2019s when\u2026wow. What an interesting little piece of history. A lot of layers to this one, too. This was fascinating, and I\u2014what I really like about this episode in particular was this was really\u2026just like one person\u2019s governorship or one, you know\u2014one in a really hairy time in history. And, you know, as he said, I think\u2014I think the fact that there was a trial for his impeachment, almost just sounds\u2014seems like a litigation of, you know\u2026Something had to be done. Nobody was doing their job. He did the best he could, but he did make mistakes and there were times where he waffled. And\u2014at the end of the day, though\u2014we can\u2019t gloss over the fact that the Klan was being terrible and needed to be stopped. At the same time, he was a bit inconsistent. He made some blunders\u2014especially the money, you know? Like it\u2019s just\u2026the art of governing, man. It\u2019s just\u2014it\u2019s messy. I think it\u2019s just a real testament to how messy these things get. And I loved the legal analyses, too. This was a really good episode, man. I really liked this one.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"auto\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"zxlms719\" id=\"viewer-zxlms719\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>TIM (1:41:27) &#8211; Well Grant, Halloween is approaching\u2014a season when ghost stories haunt the imagination and supernatural creatures parade through the night. But beneath the masks and playful frights, a more unsettling truth lurks in the darkness. Monsters are not figments of our imagination. They walk among us, sometimes in plain sight; their grotesqueness camouflaged behind a veneer of normalcy. They say, \u201cbetter the devil you know than the devil you don&#8217;t.\u201d Well, this warning proved prophetic for one sadistic predator who exploited innocence for his own psychopathic pleasure, leaving a nightmarish\u2014and almost incomprehensible\u2014hellscape in his wake. Join us as we dive deep into the annals of American infamy and dissect the life and crimes of one of the nation\u2019s most depraved serial killers\u2014next time on The American Narrative: Histories of a Nation.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div data-breakout=\"normal\">\n<ol class=\"EE2bJ rQSGI\">\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"g8lra725\" id=\"viewer-g8lra725\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Bauch, Clare T. &#8220;Holden and Pearson: A Study in the Reconstruction History of North Carolina.&#8221; Fordham University. 1949.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"3y1q610065\" id=\"viewer-3y1q610065\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Brisson, Jim D. \u201c\u2018Civil Government Was Crumbling Around Me\u2019: The Kirk-Holden War of 1870.\u201d The North Carolina Historical Review 88, no. 2 (2011): 123\u201363.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"f9ju7729\" id=\"viewer-f9ju7729\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Chen, Zirui J., and Stephanie McCurry. &#8220;The Great North Carolina Ku Klux Klan Trials.&#8221; (2023).<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"y021l731\" id=\"viewer-y021l731\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Dailey, Douglass C. \u201cTHE ELECTIONS OF 1872 IN NORTH CAROLINA.\u201d The North Carolina Historical Review 40, no. 3 (1963): 338\u201360.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"dya3q733\" id=\"viewer-dya3q733\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Gordon, Cornelia J. &#8220;No Justice Within The Law: The Murder Of Wyatt Outlaw And Its Absence From The Legal-Historical Record.&#8221;<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"hlh65735\" id=\"viewer-hlh65735\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Harris, William C. \u201cWilliam Woods Holden: In Search of Vindication.\u201d The North Carolina Historical Review 59, no. 4 (1982): 354\u201372.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"mm29n737\" id=\"viewer-mm29n737\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Massengill, Stephen E. \u201cThe Detectives of William W. Holden, 1869-1870.\u201d The North Carolina Historical Review 62, no. 4 (1985): 448\u201387.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"fwl9u739\" id=\"viewer-fwl9u739\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>McGuire, Samuel B. \u201c\u2018Rally Union Men in Defence of Your State!\u2019: Appalachian Militiamen in the Kirk-Holden War, 1870.\u201d Appalachian Journal 39, no. 3\/4 (2012): 294\u2013323.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"cpyy3741\" id=\"viewer-cpyy3741\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>McGuire, Samuel B. \u201cThe Making of a Black Militia Company: New Bern Troops in the Kirk-Holden War, 1870.\u201d The North Carolina Historical Review 91, no. 3 (2014): 288\u2013322.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li dir=\"auto\" aria-level=\"1\" class=\"YtFdT\" style=\"margin-inline-start:1.5em;list-style-type:decimal\">\n<p class=\"lkQt0 _1nK5N rQSGI oUcKW\" dir=\"\" data-ricos-paragraph=\"4c4ft36535\" id=\"viewer-4c4ft36535\" tabindex=\"-1\"><span class=\"_4K-BC\"><span>Troxler, Carole W. \u201c\u2018To Look More Closely at the Man\u2019: Wyatt Outlaw, a Nexus of National, Local, and Personal History.\u201d The North Carolina Historical Review 77, no. 4 (2000): 403\u201333.<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<\/div>\n<\/div>\n\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>DISCLAIMER (0:00) \u2013 The following program contains descriptions of violence and suggestive topics that may not be appropriate for younger audiences. Listener discretion is advised. TIM (0:10) \u2013 You\u2019re listening to The American Narrative: Histories of a Nation, a podcast series by Discover America. I\u2019m your host, Tim Murphy, alongside cohost Grant Shea, ready to [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":7074047,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[12032],"tags":[204,13211,233854,31727,3739],"dealstore":[],"offerexpiration":[],"class_list":["post-7074044","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-american-history","tag-american","tag-episode","tag-kirkholden","tag-narrative","tag-war"],"yoast_head":"<!-- This site is optimized with the Yoast SEO plugin v26.4 - https:\/\/yoast.com\/wordpress\/plugins\/seo\/ -->\n<title>The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War - Som2ny Network<\/title>\n<meta name=\"robots\" content=\"index, follow, max-snippet:-1, max-image-preview:large, max-video-preview:-1\" \/>\n<link rel=\"canonical\" href=\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:locale\" content=\"en_US\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:type\" content=\"article\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:title\" content=\"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War - Som2ny Network\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:description\" content=\"DISCLAIMER (0:00) \u2013 The following program contains descriptions of violence and suggestive topics that may not be appropriate for younger audiences. Listener discretion is advised. TIM (0:10) \u2013 You\u2019re listening to The American Narrative: Histories of a Nation, a podcast series by Discover America. I\u2019m your host, Tim Murphy, alongside cohost Grant Shea, ready to [&hellip;]\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:url\" content=\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:site_name\" content=\"Som2ny Network\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:published_time\" content=\"2026-10-26T18:14:19+00:00\" \/>\n<meta name=\"author\" content=\"admin\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:card\" content=\"summary_large_image\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:label1\" content=\"Written by\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data1\" content=\"admin\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:label2\" content=\"Est. reading time\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data2\" content=\"87 minutes\" \/>\n<script type=\"application\/ld+json\" class=\"yoast-schema-graph\">{\"@context\":\"https:\/\/schema.org\",\"@graph\":[{\"@type\":\"Article\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#article\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044\"},\"author\":{\"name\":\"admin\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/person\/b8eaddeb20a8727558e0d0cddcca426e\"},\"headline\":\"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War\",\"datePublished\":\"2026-10-26T18:14:19+00:00\",\"mainEntityOfPage\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044\"},\"wordCount\":17374,\"commentCount\":0,\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#organization\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage\"},\"thumbnailUrl\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg\",\"keywords\":[\"American\",\"Episode\",\"KirkHolden\",\"Narrative\",\"war\"],\"articleSection\":[\"American History\"],\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"CommentAction\",\"name\":\"Comment\",\"target\":[\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#respond\"]}]},{\"@type\":\"WebPage\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044\",\"url\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044\",\"name\":\"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War - Som2ny Network\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#website\"},\"primaryImageOfPage\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage\"},\"thumbnailUrl\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg\",\"datePublished\":\"2026-10-26T18:14:19+00:00\",\"breadcrumb\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#breadcrumb\"},\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"ReadAction\",\"target\":[\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044\"]}]},{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage\",\"url\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg\",\"width\":1280,\"height\":720},{\"@type\":\"BreadcrumbList\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#breadcrumb\",\"itemListElement\":[{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":1,\"name\":\"Home\",\"item\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?bp_activities=1\"},{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":2,\"name\":\"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War\"}]},{\"@type\":\"WebSite\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#website\",\"url\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/\",\"name\":\"Som2ny Network\",\"description\":\"Daily Deals\",\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#organization\"},\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"SearchAction\",\"target\":{\"@type\":\"EntryPoint\",\"urlTemplate\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?s={search_term_string}\"},\"query-input\":{\"@type\":\"PropertyValueSpecification\",\"valueRequired\":true,\"valueName\":\"search_term_string\"}}],\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\"},{\"@type\":\"Organization\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#organization\",\"name\":\"Som2ny Network\",\"url\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/\",\"logo\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/\",\"url\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/07\/4a0953c4-logo-300x86-1.png\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/07\/4a0953c4-logo-300x86-1.png\",\"width\":300,\"height\":86,\"caption\":\"Som2ny Network\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/\"}},{\"@type\":\"Person\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/person\/b8eaddeb20a8727558e0d0cddcca426e\",\"name\":\"admin\",\"image\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"en-US\",\"@id\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/person\/image\/\",\"url\":\"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/729ae85bf62b9917e93538db2f2688ca?s=96&r=g&default=https%3A%2F%2Faccountants4yourbusiness.co.uk%2Fwp-content%2Fplugins%2Fbuddypress-first-letter-avatar%2Fimages%2Fdefault%2F96%2Flatin_a.png\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/729ae85bf62b9917e93538db2f2688ca?s=96&r=g&default=https%3A%2F%2Faccountants4yourbusiness.co.uk%2Fwp-content%2Fplugins%2Fbuddypress-first-letter-avatar%2Fimages%2Fdefault%2F96%2Flatin_a.png\",\"caption\":\"admin\"},\"sameAs\":[\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\"],\"url\":\"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?author=1\"}]}<\/script>\n<!-- \/ Yoast SEO plugin. -->","yoast_head_json":{"title":"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War - Som2ny Network","robots":{"index":"index","follow":"follow","max-snippet":"max-snippet:-1","max-image-preview":"max-image-preview:large","max-video-preview":"max-video-preview:-1"},"canonical":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044","og_locale":"en_US","og_type":"article","og_title":"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War - Som2ny Network","og_description":"DISCLAIMER (0:00) \u2013 The following program contains descriptions of violence and suggestive topics that may not be appropriate for younger audiences. Listener discretion is advised. TIM (0:10) \u2013 You\u2019re listening to The American Narrative: Histories of a Nation, a podcast series by Discover America. I\u2019m your host, Tim Murphy, alongside cohost Grant Shea, ready to [&hellip;]","og_url":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044","og_site_name":"Som2ny Network","article_published_time":"2026-10-26T18:14:19+00:00","author":"admin","twitter_card":"summary_large_image","twitter_misc":{"Written by":"admin","Est. reading time":"87 minutes"},"schema":{"@context":"https:\/\/schema.org","@graph":[{"@type":"Article","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#article","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044"},"author":{"name":"admin","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/person\/b8eaddeb20a8727558e0d0cddcca426e"},"headline":"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War","datePublished":"2026-10-26T18:14:19+00:00","mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044"},"wordCount":17374,"commentCount":0,"publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#organization"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage"},"thumbnailUrl":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg","keywords":["American","Episode","KirkHolden","Narrative","war"],"articleSection":["American History"],"inLanguage":"en-US","potentialAction":[{"@type":"CommentAction","name":"Comment","target":["https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#respond"]}]},{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044","url":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044","name":"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War - Som2ny Network","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#website"},"primaryImageOfPage":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage"},"thumbnailUrl":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg","datePublished":"2026-10-26T18:14:19+00:00","breadcrumb":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#breadcrumb"},"inLanguage":"en-US","potentialAction":[{"@type":"ReadAction","target":["https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044"]}]},{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"en-US","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#primaryimage","url":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg","contentUrl":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/1793038486_maxresdefault.jpg","width":1280,"height":720},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?p=7074044#breadcrumb","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Home","item":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?bp_activities=1"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"The American Narrative Episode 5: The Kirk-Holden War"}]},{"@type":"WebSite","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#website","url":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/","name":"Som2ny Network","description":"Daily Deals","publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#organization"},"potentialAction":[{"@type":"SearchAction","target":{"@type":"EntryPoint","urlTemplate":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?s={search_term_string}"},"query-input":{"@type":"PropertyValueSpecification","valueRequired":true,"valueName":"search_term_string"}}],"inLanguage":"en-US"},{"@type":"Organization","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#organization","name":"Som2ny Network","url":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"en-US","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/","url":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/07\/4a0953c4-logo-300x86-1.png","contentUrl":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/07\/4a0953c4-logo-300x86-1.png","width":300,"height":86,"caption":"Som2ny Network"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/"}},{"@type":"Person","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/person\/b8eaddeb20a8727558e0d0cddcca426e","name":"admin","image":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"en-US","@id":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/#\/schema\/person\/image\/","url":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/729ae85bf62b9917e93538db2f2688ca?s=96&r=g&default=https%3A%2F%2Faccountants4yourbusiness.co.uk%2Fwp-content%2Fplugins%2Fbuddypress-first-letter-avatar%2Fimages%2Fdefault%2F96%2Flatin_a.png","contentUrl":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/729ae85bf62b9917e93538db2f2688ca?s=96&r=g&default=https%3A%2F%2Faccountants4yourbusiness.co.uk%2Fwp-content%2Fplugins%2Fbuddypress-first-letter-avatar%2Fimages%2Fdefault%2F96%2Flatin_a.png","caption":"admin"},"sameAs":["https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk"],"url":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/?author=1"}]}},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/7074044","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=7074044"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/7074044\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/media\/7074047"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=7074044"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=7074044"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=7074044"},{"taxonomy":"dealstore","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fdealstore&post=7074044"},{"taxonomy":"offerexpiration","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/accountants4yourbusiness.co.uk\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fofferexpiration&post=7074044"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}