Phantom Distributions and Return of Capital
Investing in registered accounts like RRSPs, TFSAs and the like avoids the messy tax complications that taxable investing can bring – including phantom distributions and return of capital.
What are phantom distributions and why are these important to understand?
Today’s post offers some details thanks to a guest post and includes some of my favourite ETFs as a small case study.
Read on!
What are Phantom Distributions and why are they important to understand?


Image credit/source: Pexels, Susan Flores.
A phantom distribution (or reinvested capital gain distribution or notional distribution) occurs when an exchange-traded fund (ETF) or mutual fund makes a taxable distribution but that’s reinvested back into the fund as opposed to being paid out in cash.
As passionate DIY investors know, I’m a huge fan of owning dividend paying stocks and low-cost ETFs – but we only own Canadian dividend paying stocks in our taxable accounts for:
- The dividend tax credit, and
- Taxation simplicity.
When it comes to taxable investing, in the case of ETFs, an investor does not usually receive additional shares as a result of a reinvested distribution hence the name here called “phantom distribution”.
Phantom distributions usually occur when an ETF (or a fund) incurs a capital gain, and the capital gain is reinvested instead of being paid out in cash.
We don’t have this problem in our household since all the Canadian dividend paying stocks we own deliver eligible dividends and those dividends are always paid out in cash, not reinvested.
Yet when phantom distributions do occur, this may not be a bad thing overall from a tracking perspective that you’ll read about in much more detail below. While your capital gain will be taxable it should also appear on your T3 or T5 slip that you receive from your brokerage. So the capital gain will be accounted for when you compile your tax slips.
However, investors need to take additional steps to ensure that their adjusted cost base (ACB) is correctly calculated when phantom distributions occur. This is where the challenges usually set in if you don’t understand them and don’t track them over time.
Today’s post looks at a few key ETFs as part of this process: phantom distributions, return of capital and tracking your ACB. In that spirit, welcome to the site: Sam Tcherner!
Sam, tell us about yourself!
Thanks Mark. I really appreciate the opportunity to share my expertise and information here!
I’m a physics PhD student in Ontario and a DIY investor with a taxable account. I got tired of entering my trades by hand every tax season and hunting through fund company documents for return of capital and reinvested distributions, so I built a tool to do it, ActiveACB. Along the way I collected the tax breakdowns for more than 200 Canadian ETFs straight from the fund companies. Every number in this post comes from those documents.
When I pitched this idea to you, you suggested comparing XIU, VEQT and HXT in a taxable account, so I pulled seven years of data for all three. A couple of results surprised me and I think all of this information will benefit your readers.
Great stuff, Sam. Do tell!
OK, Mark. Well, read on. I know you like many of these low-cost ETFs so here is the summary:
- XIU is as tax-friendly as you’d hope. Almost all of its income is eligible Canadian dividends. It still needs a little attention, though. It paid a small return of capital in six of the last seven years and a phantom distribution in 2021.
- VEQT’s return of capital is tiny, under a penny per unit a year. What VEQT does have is phantom distributions, about 75 cents per unit since 2021, and those raise your ACB.
- HXT paid nothing, so there’s nothing to track until you sell. For an Ontario investor earning about $100,000, that deferral was worth almost nothing after tax over this period. In the top bracket it was worth about $900 per $10,000 invested.
(You wrote an older post on tax efficient investing before Horizons ETFs rebranded to Global X.)
Of note: HXT has also become slightly more expensive over time. Since January 2025 it pays its banks a swap fee of up to 0.20% a year on top of its 0.08% MER, and in 2025 it trailed XIU after beating it every year from 2016 to 2024.
Let’s get into the details!!
Return of capital and phantom distributions in one minute
ROC and phantom distributions both change your adjusted cost base (ACB), in opposite directions.
Return of capital (ROC) is cash you receive that isn’t taxed when it’s paid. It lowers your ACB instead, so you pay the tax later when you sell. (If ROC ever pushes your ACB below zero, the amount below zero is a capital gain that year and your ACB resets to zero.) It shows up in Box 42 of your T3 slip, and the CRA’s instruction is short:
“If box 42 contains a positive amount, subtract this amount from the ACB of the units of the trust.”
A phantom distribution is like you mentioned a taxable distribution paid in new units instead of cash. The fund consolidates its units right away, so your unit count doesn’t change and nothing shows up in your account. You’re still taxed on it, “because the CRA considers you to have received these amounts before reinvesting them.” Since you paid tax on money that went back into the fund, it raises your ACB. On the T3 it’s usually lumped in with the other capital gains in Box 21, so the slip won’t tell you how much came as units. The fund company’s tax breakdown will, usually labelled “reinvested” or “non-cash”.
Miss the ROC and your ACB is too high, so you report too small a gain when you sell. If the CRA reassesses, you owe the difference plus interest.
Miss a phantom distribution and your ACB is too low, so you pay tax on the same dollars twice. Don’t count on the CRA to catch that one for you.
Messy!
Let’s look at the math.
Seven years of distributions, per unit
From the iShares “Distribution Characteristics” files and Vanguard’s annual distribution history:
| Year | XIU cash | XIU ROC | XIU phantom | VEQT cash | VEQT ROC | VEQT phantom |
| 2019 | $0.733 | $0.1007 | – | $0.404 | $0.0055 | – |
| 2020 | $0.789 | $0.1394 | – | $0.462 | $0.0076 | – |
| 2021 | $0.791 | – | $0.1092 | $0.514 | $0.0082 | $0.1277 |
| 2022 | $0.895 | $0.0208 | – | $0.672 | $0.0024 | $0.2450 |
| 2023 | $1.013 | $0.1536 | – | $0.692 | $0.0046 | $0.0535 |
| 2024 | $1.094 | $0.0832 | – | $0.713 | $0.0064 | $0.0819 |
| 2025 | $1.125 | $0.0151 | – | $0.760 | $0.0071 | $0.2425 |
| Total | $6.440 | $0.5128 | $0.1092 | $4.218 | $0.0417 | $0.7507 |
HXT isn’t in the table because it paid no distributions at all.
XIU’s ROC is spread across its quarterly payments, a few cents or less each time. VEQT pays once a year, with a late-December record date and the payment in early January. Since 2021 its capital gains have all come as phantom units.
What that did to $10,000 in each fund – a case study
Say you put $10,000 into each fund on February 5, 2019, VEQT’s first day of trading, took the distributions as cash, and looked at your position at the end of 2025. I’ve used fractional units to keep the dollar amounts round.
| XIU | VEQT | HXT | |
| Cash distributions for 2019 to 2025 | $2,723 | $1,657 | $0 |
| ROC (lowers ACB) | -$217 | -$16 | $0 |
| Phantom distributions (raise ACB) | +$46 | +$295 | $0 |
| ACB at the end of 2025 | $9,829 | $10,279 | $10,000 |
| Capital gain if sold Dec 31, 2025 | $10,040 | $10,826 | $14,583 |
| Tax on distributions along the way (Ontario, ~$100k income) | $238 | $299 | $0 |
| Tax error if you left ACB at $10,000 | $27 underpaid | $44 overpaid | none |
HXT’s gain looks bigger because its whole return is in the price. XIU and VEQT paid part of theirs out along the way.
The errors per $10,000 are small, but they scale with the size of the position and how long you hold it. On a $200,000 position they’re about 20 times larger at the same tax rates. They also point in opposite directions, so one rule of thumb doesn’t cover both funds.
XIU: tax-efficient, with a little homework
I know you like this ETF for taxable investing, Mark, as your when in doubt ETF to own vs. any Canadian stock picking and I can see why.
In 2025, $1.110 of XIU’s $1.125 in distributions per unit was eligible Canadian dividends. At about $100,000 of income in Ontario those are taxed at 8.92%, so the $476 our example investor received in 2025 cost them $42 in tax.
Not very much.
The homework is the ROC.
It was small, but it came with every quarterly payment from 2019 through 2025 except in 2021, when XIU paid out capital gains instead, partly as a year-end phantom distribution. Ignore both for seven years and the ACB on our $10,000 ends up $171 too high, a $27 tax shortfall at a $100,000 income. That’s small, but it’s the kind of error the CRA cares about.
So “XIU is simple” and tax efficient holds up, as long as simple includes entering two dozen small ROC amounts over seven years, or reading Box 42 each spring.
VEQT: forget the ROC, watch December
I then looked at VEQT, a popular all-in-one ETF to own including for some DIY investors as part of taxable investing.
VEQT’s ROC added up to about four cents per unit over seven years, $16 on our $10,000. You still have to subtract it, but the dollar impact is tiny.
The phantom distributions matter more.
VEQT’s year-end distributions for 2021 through 2025 paid its capital gains as units: 12.8, 24.5, 5.3, 8.2 and 24.3 cents per unit. Our investor paid tax on $295 they never received as cash. Leave that out of the ACB and they pay tax on it again when they sell, about $46 at a $100,000 income. (The $44 in the table is net of the $16 of ROC.)
VEQT’s income is also taxed differently. The biggest piece is foreign income, taxed like interest, with a credit for the foreign tax already withheld. Counting the phantom distribution, the tax on VEQT’s 2025 distributions came to about 20% of the cash it paid out, against about 9% for XIU. The phantom accounts for about 5 points of that, and the foreign income for most of the rest.
So, these things are worth knowing before you decide which account VEQT goes in.
HXT: nothing to track, and a different set of questions
Finally, I looked at HXT.
HXT holds no stocks. It holds cash and a total return swap with two banks, currently National Bank and CIBC, that pays it the return of the S&P/TSX 60 with dividends included. The dividends end up in the share price, so there’s nothing to pay out. Global X says investors “are not expected to receive any taxable distributions,” and I couldn’t find a single distribution since HXT launched in 2010.
For ACB, that makes HXT the easy one. Your ACB is what you paid, and your whole return is a capital gain when you sell. A few things are still worth knowing:
- HXT like I mentioned above costs more than it used to. The MER is 0.08%, but since January 1, 2025 HXT has also paid its banks a swap fee of up to 0.20% a year. That fee shows up in the trading expense ratio (0.18% for 2025), not the MER, so it’s easy to miss. Going by the annual returns each fund reports, HXT beat XIU by 0.07 to 0.18 percentage points a year from 2019 to 2024. In 2025 it trailed by 0.16.
- HXT is one share class of a larger company, now Global X Canada ETF Corp., which also holds 18 other corporate-class ETFs and the BetaPro leveraged and inverse ETFs. The company is taxed as one entity, so gains and losses in one class can offset another. Its prospectus says it “may pay Capital Gains Dividends on a regular basis, in particular if it uses Physically Settled Derivatives,” and the 2025 prospectus says Global X may start using them. None has been paid so far. If one ever is, it would come on a T5 rather than a T3.
- Finally, if you’ve held HXT since before December 2019, check your ACB for that year. HXT was a trust until November 29, 2019, when it converted to a corporate class after a change in the 2019 federal budget. The switch was tax-deferred for taxable-account holders who filed a joint Section 85 election with Horizons. Without that election, it would generally have counted as a sale at market value, which resets your ACB.
Interesting, I looked at this:
Here’s how XIU and HXT compare on the same index.
XIU’s distributions are reinvested on each pay date: all of the cash in the before-tax row, and what’s left after tax in the after-tax rows. Fees and HXT’s swap costs are already in the prices.
| $10,000 on Feb 5, 2019, sold Dec 31, 2025 | XIU | HXT |
| Before tax | $24,465 | $24,583 |
| After tax, Ontario, ~$100k income | $22,225 | $22,288 |
| After tax, Ontario, top bracket | $19,759 | $20,681 |
At a $100,000 income it’s close to a tie.
XIU’s eligible dividends were taxed at 8.92% each year, while HXT turns the same dividends into capital gains, taxed at 15.74% when you sell. The deferral and the higher rate roughly cancel out. In the top bracket, eligible dividends are taxed at 39.34% against 26.76% for capital gains, and HXT comes out about $900 ahead.
Mind you, the longer you hold HXT without selling, the more the deferral is worth.
The XIU column also needed 28 reinvestment purchases, each one another entry in your ACB records.
Six of those seven years came before the swap fee, though. At current costs HXT runs about 0.26% to 0.27% a year all in, against XIU’s 0.17% MER. Going forward, the tie at a $100,000 income would likely tip toward XIU, and HXT’s top-bracket advantage would shrink.
What I’d actually do – a summary on phantom distributions
- Keep your own record of every buy and sell in a taxable account. Your broker’s book value is a useful check, but it isn’t always adjusted for ROC or phantom distributions, and you’re the one filing the return.
- Each spring, pull the fund company’s tax breakdown for every fund you hold in a taxable account. That’s the “Distribution Characteristics” file at iShares, the annual distribution history at Vanguard, and the equivalent at BMO and others. Subtract ROC (or use Box 42 on your T3) and add any reinvested or non-cash amounts.
- If you DRIP in a taxable account, each reinvestment is a purchase that goes into your ACB.
- If that sounds like too much, think about which account the fund sits in. Inside a TFSA or RRSP, none of this matters like you mentioned above. 🙂
A spreadsheet works fine for one or two funds.
You can look up the ROC and phantom distributions for about 240 Canadian ETFs at activeacb.ca/etf-tax-factors.html, and every row links back to the fund company’s own document.
Thanks for having me, Mark. A pleasure.
Thanks, Sam.
Readers, have you experienced phantom distributions? Did you know how to manage them? Again, this only applies to taxable investing but if you invest in a non-registered account this must be managed based on what you own. Thanks for your readership.
Disclosure/Notes:
This is a guest post from Sam Tcherner, founder of ActiveACB, an adjusted cost base calculator for Canadian investors. None of this content constitutes investing or tax advice. These are examples for educational and illustration purposes only.
How the numbers were built: distributions are from iShares and Vanguard tax documents for 2019 to 2025, counted by record date, so VEQT’s 2025 distribution (paid in January 2026) is included. Prices are TSX closes, from TMX Money for Feb 5, 2019 and Dec 31, 2025 and from Yahoo Finance for XIU’s reinvestment dates. No commissions. Tax uses 2025 Ontario combined marginal rates from TaxTips.ca for every year at a single fixed rate, so it ignores a large gain in the year of sale pushing part of itself into a higher bracket. It assumes the foreign tax credit is fully claimed and ignores capital losses from other holdings and income-tested benefits such as the OAS clawback. In the reinvestment comparison, the tax on XIU’s 2021 phantom distribution comes out of its next cash payment. The HXT figures assume the investor filed the Section 85 election in 2019, so their ACB carried over. Again, all illustration and never tax advice.
