Product Review: Pod Drop


In thirty years of writing articles for and about the aquarium industry, I’ve never actually written a product review. My only mention of products and brands has been part of documenting protocols for the various endeavors (mostly breeding) in which I’ve engaged. However, a recent incident has inspired me to break my longstanding silence and offer my thoughts on a product, and more importantly, a trend I’m seeing in the hobby. It started when one of my former students (let’s call him…..Payton) contacted me for advice on setting up a home fish hatchery. We reviewed multiple topics, including species choice, system design, broodstock acquisition, live feeds culture, and marketing. I reminded him that if he had taken good notes in all of my classes, he should have access to all of the information he was seeking. Of course, he didn’t, which is why I enjoyed pointing that out. He was passionate and motivated, but had a hard time staying awake through a lecture. I guess I’m trying to say, he reminded me of me.

After almost a year of semi-regular conversations, he called me one afternoon, completely elated. His pair of green-banded gobies had just spawned for the first time and he needed to get his plankton cultures started. I told him (and he knew), they should have been started months ago, but there was no point in discussing anything but how to move forward. He got some bulk algae and algae starters from the college lab and told me he was going to order fresh copepod cultures (even though I offered him some of ours).

A few days later I got a call from this budding young aquaculturist. He told me his copepods had just arrived and he asked if he could bring them by the lab so we could assess them under the microscope. “Of course” I said. “And by the way, where did you get them from.” There was a bit of a silence. Then he told me he got them from a company/website called Pod Drop. There was another pause, this time from my end. “Why did you do that?” He knew better. I had told him on multiple occasions, that when it’s time to order cultures, you need to get them from a reputable source, so you can be sure that you’re starting with a pure, uncontaminated, single-species culture. As far as I know, in the US, your two choices are Algagen and Reed Mariculture. Anyone else selling copepods online, probably bought cultures from one of them and are trying to keep them going while selling them to hobbyists. Almost invariably, this results in customers not getting what they’ve paid for.

I took it upon myself to peruse the Pod Drop website while I waited. I must admit, it was impressive – user friendly and full of nice graphics and somewhat relevant information. Maybe I was wrong. There were also multiple statements about product quality and purity, as well as a live arrival guarantee. Here are some direct quotes from the website:

There was however, a red flag. All instructions, for all plankton products that they offered involved adding them to reef aquaria. Nothing about feeding it to larvae or using it to start a culture. This tells me that their target customer is not someone who needs a pure culture, but rather, someone who is going to pour the entire bottle into their reef system on arrival, where the plankton will be fed upon by corals, and perhaps initiate a self-sustaining population. Of course, a pelagic copepod like Parvocalanus sp. can’t possibly complete a life cycle in an aquarium with standard filtration, so at best, this might serve as a very expensive, single-serving meal for the tank. 

About thirty minutes after our phone conversation, the student showed up with his shipping box. He pulled out two identical plastic bottles labeled: Parvo Pods.

At least the label indicated that the product could be used to feed larval fishes. I held one bottle up to the light, and then the other. My aging eyes could make out some suspended particles in the water, but they didn’t appear to be moving and they didn’t look like copepods. Using a pipette, I took a small sample out from each bottle and prepared a wet mount microscope slide. As always, I started at the lowest magnification for our compound scopes: 40X. That should allow me to easily see Parvocalanus sp. at any stage in development. A search of both slides revealed no copepods of any kind. I was able to make out some very tiny organisms gliding around, likely some type of ciliated protozoan. Before moving up to a higher magnification, I decided to concentrate the entire contents of both bottles into just a few milliliters so that we would have an easier time finding whatever might be in the water. I got out a 35-micron sieve, poured all of the water through, and rinsed the contents into a small beaker. There was no increase in the concentration of ciliates, which tells me that they were smaller than 35 microns. There was a lot of detritus, and after several minutes of searching, we were able to find one living copepod. Not surprisingly, it was not Parvocalanus. It was a harpacticoid copepod – the type you see crawling around on the glass of virtually all established marine aquaria. I told my student he should contact the seller immediately and demand a full refund. There was literally nothing useful in either of these bottles. Whether this was the result of terrible quality control or a blatant scam was really immaterial. He had a time sensitive-need for these copepods, he paid for them, and he didn’t get them.

The single copepod that was found after concentrating all the water in both bottles (100X magnification)

Payton tried calling right then while I eagerly waited to hear the explanation. There was no answer, so he left a message. After four days of leaving messages with no response, he sent an expletive-heavy text to the number, calling the seller out as a fraud and a scammer.  The text did the trick and he finally got a call from the seller. There was no explanation. Just an offer to send more product. Payton declined the offer and insisted on a refund. To the seller’s credit, a refund was eventually issued. However, I believe the complete absence of Parvocalanus in both bottles, and the long delay in responding to the issue, fully justifies my official review, which is: One star, would not recommend. 

Now, I’m not accusing the seller of purposely shipping bottles of essentially nothing. I think it’s much more likely that this is a case of poor quality control. Maybe the cultures crashed, but the seller went through the motions of harvesting, bottling, and shipping anyway. Maybe the copepods were bottled too soon and died when the oxygen and/or food was depleted in the bottle. Either way, the result was that the buyer ended up with two bottles of dirty water – not the pure Parvocalanus culture that was advertised. Had the buyer been a reef hobbyist with no access to a microscope, they would likely have poured the contents into their tank without ever knowing.

Interestingly, since this incident, Pod Drop ads have been appearing on my Facebook feed and they have even tried to make promotional posts on the Aquaculture page I administer for Carteret Community College. The posts feature what appear to be AI-generated photos of “scientists” in lab coats working in a pristine laboratory setting.  

The take-home message is: If you need live plankton, get it from a reputable source like Algagen or Reed and make sure you have the tools needed to assess the cultures. Don’t fall for flashy websites and planted testimonials without at least checking some real, live human references.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart