Black History in Contemporary Graphic Narratives


reviewed by Brian Flota, James Madison University

Daniel
Stein’s third scholarly monograph offers a substantial contribution to Black
Comics Studies. A German professor of Literary and Cultural Studies at the
University of Siegen in Germany, he builds on his earlier comics scholarship,
most notably his second book Authorizing Superhero Comics: On the Evolution
of a Popular Serial Genre
(2021, Ohio State UP), by delving into graphic
narratives that, in part, grapple with the legacy of slavery and its aftermath
in the United States, especially those that engage in the paradox, of
artistically rendering these legacies, identified by Toni Morrison: “Forgetting
[slavery] is unacceptable. Remembering is unacceptable” (7). Across five
chapters, Stein examines comics with narratives that incorporate depictions of
the Middle Passage, lynching, the Civil Rights Movement, “Afrodiasporic archives,”
and the use of monsters and monstrosity as a means of confronting, revisiting,
and reconfiguring these histories, histories often ignored or intentionally
expunged from officially sanctioned “the archive.”

In
the introduction, Stein points out one quality that unites each of the
narratives he examines throughout the course of the book: they confront the
“legacies of racial depiction” in US visual culture and seek to “overcome the
creative and cultural limitations inscribed in racist visual culture by
satirizing Black stereotypes” (7). Furthermore, this specific set of graphic
texts “negotiate the tension between recovering archival traces of the past
(remembering) and redressing the loss of Black life recorded in the archive as
an alternative to willful forgetting” (10). Chapter One, “Middle Passage
Epistemologies,” as such, hones in on three texts in particular: Tom Feelings’ The
Middle Passage: White Ships/Black Cargo
(1995), Kyle Baker’s Nat Turner
(2008), and Rebecca Hall, Hugo Martinez, and Sarula Bao’s Wake: The Hidden
History of Women-Led Slave Revolts
(2021). Each of these works confronts
centuries of racist textual and visual tropes by drawing from the archive, as
well as its erasures, by, as Stein writes about Wake, “imagining
alternative origin stories, both familial and communal, for their protagonists
and their ancestors and descendants” (22). This is necessary, Stein argues, for
the writers and artists of these narratives to take back ownership of
experiences that have been deleted, misrepresented, or overdetermined by the
cogs in the machinery of white supremacy. As a result, these three works
necessarily take liberties with the source material, filling in gaps, imagining
alternative histories, and challenging existing narratives, histories, and
archives rooted in the events these artists and writers portray. 

Chapter
Two, “Legacies of Lynching,” revisits Baker’s Nat Turner while also
turning to Jeremy Love and Patrick Morgan’s Bayou (2009-10). One of
Stein’s central arguments in the chapter is drawn from Chris Gavaler’s
important 2013 article “The Ku Klux Klan and the Birth of the Superhero,” which
argues that the early creators of superheroes would have been bombarded with
popular cultural expressions of (racist) vigilantism, particularly Thomas Dixon
Jr.’s The Clansman (1906), which served as the basis for D.W. Griffith’s
The Birth of a Nation (1915), which is generally considered to be
America’s first feature-length film. The hooded (in the case of the Ku Klux
Klan) heroes of these works evolved into the masked protagonists soon
populating pulp magazines, which would be supplanted by comic books and the
popularity of vigilante superheroes not long after the first appearance of
Superman in Action Comics #1 (1938). These heroes were given alter egos
that served to protect their private identities from their very public form of
“speech.” For example, Stein points out that Baker provides Nat Turner with a
new “origin story” bearing some resemblance to Bruce Wayne’s as Batman (80).
When discussing Mat Johnson and Warren Pleece’s Incognegro (2008), he
observes Johnson and Pleece make a direct connection between the passing
narrative ascribed to the light-skinned Black man Zane Pinchback and his
assumed alter ego as Incognegro (82). As Stein argues, “A disparity certainly
exists between the momentous history of American slavery and a popular serial
genre like superhero comics, but this history is so formative for modern
entertainment and its wake so expansive that genres that do not explicitly deal
with this history–and even those that even ignore or deny it–cannot escape its
specter” (79-80). He uses this ignored aspect of the origin of superheroes more
broadly to inform his readings of Nat Turner and Bayou, which
both, as he points out, slyly allude to this history in their depictions of
lynching.

The
next two chapters are not as scintillating as the first two, though they still
pack quite a wallop. Chapter Three focuses on John Lewis, Andrew Aydin, and
Nate Powell’s March (2013-2016) and Ho Che Anderson’s King
(1993-2003) with particular attention to the text’s didactic qualities and the
various ways they cleave to or subvert the male-dominated “master narratives”
of the Civil Rights Movement. Despite arguing that March offers an (at
times) conservative (with a lower-case “c”) perspective on the movement, he
also claims that the three-volume graphic novel both manages to appeal to a
much broader set of audiences than Anderson’s more experimental biography of
Martin Luther King and does so with complex points of view that go beyond
Lewis’. Chapter Four offers a discussion of the “Afrodiasporic archive,” and
does so by examining the Black Panther series and affiliated titles that
appeared during writer Ta-Nehisi Coates’ run on the character. While this
section does return to themes brought up in earlier chapters, particularly as
it relates to “the archive,” here, Stein focuses on the speculative politics of
the archive when set in the fictional African nation Wakanda. Of particular
note is Stein’s use of Abigail De Kosnik’s concept of the “rogue archive,” in
which all the products of mass media culture become their users’ own archive to
plunder. Stein also points out how Coates, Roxane Gay, and Nnedi Okorafor
interact with the very real archive of Marvel back issues and how they plays
with “memory management” and “corporate narrative memory” to “retroactively
reshap[e] it, including Marvel’s decision to make its first Black superhero
hail from Africa as a way of sidestepping racial tensions in mid-1960s America”
(154).

Stein
concludes the book with a chapter titled “Monstrous Pasts.” Here, Stein
explains why the monster figure, or monstrosity more broadly, is an effective
trope for the writers and artists of the graphic narratives he considers in the
chapter, including Bayou, several projects featuring the involvement of
John Jennings (Blue Hand Mojo: Hard Times Road [2017], The Mighty
Struggle: A Town Called Miracle
[2022] with David Brame, and Box of
Bones
[2018-present], with Ayize Jama-Everett), David F. Walker, Chuck
Brown, and Sanford Greene’s Bitter Root (2018-2021), and Rob Guillory’s Farmhand
(2018-2022). He explains, “All of these works approach the traumas of the
past as well as the traumas of everyday life in the Black diaspora through
monstrous figures or figurations of monstrousness, utilizing the expressive
potential of graphic narrative to challenge culturally pervasive associations
of blackness and monstrosity (and vice versa) that have for centuries plagued
Black communities” (168-9). Stein also uses Jennings’ (and Stanford
Carpenter’s) concept of the “ethnogothic” – which fuses elements historically
associated with the gothic (ghosts, haunted houses, doppelgangers) with the
cultural traumas associated with the Black experience in America – to frame his
reading of these texts, particularly in his observation of “the South” as “both
a cursed and an enchanted place” in the narratives he has singled out. Drawing from
theories of monstrosity by scholars such as Jeffrey Cohen, Stein does an expert
job teasing out the particular reasons that these comics creators are able to
skillfully fuse Black history into the monsters, specters, and haunted spaces
that populate the texts mentioned in the chapter.

Ultimately,
I highly recommend Strange Fruit and Bitter Roots to prospective readers
for several reasons. Stein is thoroughly knowledgeable about comics as well
African American literature, history, and theory. His breadth of knowledge
yields a book that, while loaded with dense and theoretical takes on similarly dense
and complex graphic novels, is never overwhelming when wielding these
theoretical tools. By offering careful readings of these works while balancing
the written word as well as their visual components, Stein offers a masterclass
in Comics Studies scholarship with his latest book.

Editor’s note – I apologize to Brian Flota for the delay in publishing this; he submitted it in May, but it got lost in my email. 

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart