
Mike Magee
A few days ago, the world of art and literature celebrated the centennial of John Berger’s birth (November 5, 1926). Described as a “liberator of images,” his 1972 book and the accompanying BBC series (Ways of Seeing) was literally “an eye opener” for professionals and academics involved in every aspect of cultural study.
He was still being actively quoted at the time of his death at 91 on January 2, 2017. For example this: “Seeing comes before words. The child looks and recognizes before it can speak. But there is another sense in which seeing comes before words. It is seeing which establishes our place in the surrounding world…”
In 1964, eight years before Berger’s work, in chapter 1 of his book, Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man, Marshall McLuhan famously introduced the phrase, “the medium is the message.” Berger likely took notice, especially since his reflections on the “surrounding world” included the changing patterns and sizing and timing of human exposure to information.
Berger perhaps more than anyone else understood the impact of visual images. As he wrote, “One may remember or forget these messages but briefly one takes them in, and for a moment they stimulate the imagination by way of memory or expectation.”
Berger wrote convincingly about publicity and celebrity a half century before Trump knocked down the East Wing of the White House or created rough sketches of his Triumphant Arch. He saw publicity, pre-internet, as “closely related to certain ideas about freedom: freedom of choice for the purchaser: freedom of enterprise for the manufacturer . . . immediate visible signs of ‘The Free World’.”
Why did masses of Americans buy into Trump’s promises? Berger suggests an answer tying consumption (of products or ideas) to image. In his words: “We transform ourselves, or our lives, by buying something more. This more, it (or Trump) proposes, will make us in some way richer – even though we will be poorer by having spent our money. Publicity persuades…by showing us people who have apparently been transformed, and are, as a result, enviable. The state of being envied is what constitutes glamour. And publicity is the process of manufacturing glamour.”
But Trump is very careful to maintain his distance (and deniability). Why? What is his end game? Berger states, “Being envied is a solitary form of reassurance It depends precisely upon not sharing your experience with those who envy you. You are observed with interest but you do not observe with interest – if you do, you will become less enviable. In this respect the envied are like bureaucrats; the more impersonal they are the greater the illusion (for themselves and for others) of their power.”
But where does the power reside? “The power of the glamorous resides in their supposed happiness: the power of the bureaucrat in his supposed authority….All publicity works on anxiety. The sum of everything is money, to get money is to overcome anxiety. Alternately the anxiety on which publicity plays is the fear that having nothing you will be nothing.”
For Trump, losing money (and power or elections) has often closely trailed attaining them. The fear of being a loser is enough to trigger over-exaggerated and showy responses. As Berger sees it “Publicity images often use sculptures or paintings to lend allure or authority to their own message.” Were Berger on stage a month ago when President Obama said of Trump’s Oval Office, “What’s up with the gold?” he would likely have responded, “It’s his idea of fine art.”
Trump’s clumsiness in pursuing artsy beautification projects reached its’ nadir with the reflecting pool fiasco. To the President, the dull gray reflecting pool was a perfect metaphor for the voter who was “marginally dissatisfied with his present way of life.” In pursuit of the perfect “American flag blue”, he suggested that if the voter “bought what he was offering, his life would become better.” The new reflecting pool was to be “an improved alternative to what he (the voter) was.” But it backfired.
“Those who have power become lovable,” declared Berger. But as layers of blue paint peeled away and dangled in the sacred pool, all of the public was reminded of why Americans coalesced around the “NO KINGS” mantra, and were found repeating among themselves the 1613 quote attributed to Sir Thomas Overbury, “Beauty is only (orange) skin deep.”