Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value in NC


Quick answer: It depends on your North Carolina policy. Replacement cost pays to repair or replace without subtracting for age. Actual cash value (ACV) subtracts depreciation, so the check is smaller. Some policies pay replacement cost on the house but ACV on the roof or belongings. Your declarations page, loss settlement section and endorsements show which applies.

What we see at ALLCHOICE

A pattern we see often: A homeowner with an older roof files a wind or hail claim and finds out the roof is paid at actual cash value, even though the rest of the house is not. The check comes in below the repair estimate, and the difference is depreciation. The homeowner covers it out of pocket, on top of the deductible.

What usually causes the surprise: The roof wording sits in an endorsement, which is easy to miss when you are comparing prices. Few homeowners go looking for it until they need it.

What helps: Checking how the roof is paid before a storm, not after one. An independent Risk Advisor can read the endorsements for you and compare how different carriers handle roofs.

Not sure whether your roof is paid at replacement cost or ACV? Your Risk Advisor can read your policy with you, or we can compare homeowners options across carriers.

Get a home insurance quote

What is the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value?

Replacement cost pays what it costs to repair or replace damaged property with similar materials, without subtracting for age or wear. Actual cash value pays the replacement amount minus depreciation. The North Carolina Department of Insurance (NCDOI) explains that an ACV-only policy pays the depreciated amount.

Compare Replacement cost Actual cash value (ACV)
What it pays The cost to repair or replace with similar materials, up to your policy limits The replacement cost minus depreciation
Age and wear Not subtracted Subtracted
Size of the check Closer to the repair bill Smaller, and often smaller on older property
Your deductible Still applies Still applies
Cost of coverage Often higher, since it pays more Often lower

How much would insurance pay on a roof claim?

The gap between the two is the depreciation. In the illustration below, ACV pays $8,000 less than replacement cost, and that difference is the depreciation.

Illustration only, not a quote or a prediction. Assume a covered roof loss with a replacement cost of $20,000, a $2,500 deductible and $8,000 of depreciation.

Step Replacement cost Actual cash value (ACV)
Cost to repair or replace $20,000 $20,000
Depreciation subtracted $0 $8,000
Deductible subtracted $2,500 $2,500
Insurance payment $17,500 $9,500

Your deductible may not be a flat amount. NCDOI says deductibles can be a fixed amount or a percentage of your dwelling coverage, and that some policies carry a separate windstorm, hail or named storm deductible. Under replacement cost coverage, the insurer may pay the ACV amount first and release the depreciation after repairs, as covered below.

How does ACV work on a roof claim in North Carolina?

The insurer works out the cost to repair or replace the damaged roofing, then subtracts depreciation for the roof’s age and condition. You get that smaller amount, minus your deductible. The older the roof, the bigger the gap tends to be.

Two details from NCDOI are worth knowing. First, NCDOI’s FAQs say the insurer only has to replace the damaged area of a roof, even if the shingles will not match. Second, in Accardi v. Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co., decided February 28, 2020, the North Carolina Supreme Court held that an insurer could depreciate labor costs, not just materials, when calculating ACV under the policy at issue. That is a court ruling, and how it applies to a particular claim is a question for an attorney.

For more on how roofs affect your coverage, see our guide to what type of roofs insurance companies like most.

Which parts of my policy pay replacement cost, and which pay ACV?

It can differ by coverage. A policy can pay one way for the house and another way for the roof or your personal belongings. Depending on your policy and carrier, an endorsement may change how a certain type of loss is settled, and some carriers use their own forms. Look for these places in your paperwork:

  • The declarations page, which lists your coverages and any endorsements.
  • The loss settlement section of the policy, which says how a covered loss is valued.
  • Any roof surfacing or wind and hail endorsement, which can change how roof damage is paid.

Then ask your Risk Advisor one direct question: If a covered storm damages my roof today, will my policy pay replacement cost or actual cash value, and will the depreciation be recoverable?

Can I get the depreciation back later?

Sometimes, and it depends on which kind of policy you have. Under replacement cost coverage, NCDOI says the insurer may first pay the actual cash value and reimburse the extra money, called recoverable depreciation, once the property is repaired or replaced and you submit receipts. NCDOI’s FAQs add that if you claim on an ACV basis first, you may then make a claim within 180 days after the loss for additional reimbursement under your policy’s loss settlement provisions. Your policy sets the exact steps and timing, so confirm them with your carrier.

If your policy pays ACV only, you receive the depreciated amount, and completing repairs does not by itself bring a second payment.

For a look at how replacement cost comes up in a fire claim, see our post on turkey fryer fires and homeowners insurance.

What this means in North Carolina

Roofs take the brunt of wind and hail, so the roof is where this difference tends to show up. In 2012, the North Carolina Rate Bureau introduced an endorsement (form HO 04 93 10 00) for the homeowners program that settles wind or hail losses to roof surfacing at actual cash value, effective September 25, 2012. Whether your policy includes it, or a similar carrier form, depends on your carrier and how the policy was written.

That is why the roof deserves its own line in your review, whether you live in the Triad, the mountains or on the coast. As an independent agency, we compare how carriers handle roofs, so you can see the trade-off between a lower premium and a larger roof claim check.

If you have a question about a denied or reduced claim, NCDOI lists a consumer line of 855-408-1212 in its homeowners FAQs.

People also ask

Final verdict

Replacement cost and actual cash value can change what you are paid by a lot, especially on an older roof. The time to find out which one you have is before a storm.

Compare home insurance quotes from multiple carriers

Already a client? Visit the Member Center or call your Risk Advisor to review how your roof is covered.

Related: Home insurance in North Carolina · Turkey fryer fires and your homeowners policy · What type of roofs insurance companies like most

Sources

Coverage depends on your policy, carrier and situation. This article is general information, not a coverage decision — talk to your Risk Advisor about your policy.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart