How to Give Feedback to Employees in a Nonprofit


How to prepare for feedback conversations with leadership coach Kathy Archer

You know that feeling when you finally make it to the store for new shoes? Yours are looking less than stellar, and the bigwigs will be at tomorrow’s meeting, so you figure you’d better up your game a bit.

It’s the end of the day. You’ve had back-to-back meetings since 8:30. You’re tired, you’re hangry, and you’ve got 15 minutes before you need to pick up the kids.

So you grab the first respectable-looking pair in your size, slip them on for a few seconds, and head to the till.

The next day, you feel blisters forming on both heels before lunch. And you wonder how you can sneak away to find Band-Aids and put them on without anyone noticing.

Here’s the thing. If you’d had a bit longer, you’d have walked around the store and noticed they pinched.

Feedback conversations are the same. When we squeeze them in between meetings, at the end of a long day, without a plan, they rub everybody the wrong way.

If feedback feels like criticism, most people get defensive. If it helps them see what’s going on, they’re much more likely to do something about it. And that’s our job as nonprofit leaders: to grow our people.
​
That kind of feedback takes some planning before you ever sit down with your staff member.

How do you give effective feedback to employees?

​The number one tip is to prepare for feedback conversations. Decide how you want the person to feel and what you want them to do, gather objective examples, and schedule the conversation for when you’re at your best. During the conversation, connect, ask open-ended how and what questions, and let them come up with solutions. Afterwards, follow up in your next one-to-one.
​
When I coach clients through a feedback conversation, we use the Infinite Leadership Loop, the five-step model from my book Character Driven Leadership for Women: PAUSE, PONDER, PIVOT, PROCEED, and PEOPLE. Here’s how it works for feedback.
Infinite Leadership Loop by Kathy Archer showing five steps: PAUSE, PONDER, PIVOT, PROCEED, and PEOPLE.

How to prepare for a feedback conversation (PAUSE and PONDER)

When you PAUSE to prepare, you need to PONDER. I know, that’s a lot of P’s. The point is, you need to think it through instead of jumping straight into the conversation. I always tell my clients to start with the end in mind, then work backwards. So, begin by picturing the end of the meeting.
​
After the meeting: How do you want your staff member to feel when they walk out? What action do you want them to take? Write it down so you’re clear.

During the meeting: How do they need to feel in the room for that outcome to happen? And to get there, how do you need to show up? Patient? Curious? Open-minded?

Before the meeting: What do you need to do to have that impact? This is where the prep comes in.

  • Plan the timing. PONDER the best time to schedule your conversation. Avoid squeezing it between back-to-back meetings. Give yourself time to gather your thoughts and take a bio break. Also think about the time of day. 3 PM, when you’re drained and hangry, may not be ideal. Giving yourself time to think may help you PIVOT to a new perspective. You might realize it’s better to schedule it earlier in the day, when you’ve got more left in the tank.
  • Gather your information. You don’t want to come at it like a detective, but you do want to know what happened, when, and how often. Aim to be observational rather than judgmental, and note the impact of their behaviour. “You’re intimidating with clients” is just a wee bit judgmental. “When you stood over the client while they were sitting, I noticed they stopped talking with you” is more objective.
  • Check your assumptions. What have you already decided about them? “They don’t care.” “They should know better by now!” “They’ll get defensive no matter what I say.” If you go in with these assumptions, they’ll taint how you engage with them. Instead, see them as someone who wants to do well. Something is just getting in the way, and your job as a leader is to help them get past it.
  • Plan your opening. Write down your first sentence or two. The start is usually the hardest part, and knowing how you’ll begin keeps you from rambling or softening it too much. If it’s a tough one, it’s okay to name that. I call this narrating the conversation. You might say, “This isn’t easy for me to bring up, but it matters.”
  • Prepare yourself. Think ahead about where you might get triggered during the conversation, and plan how you’ll keep or regain your composure. Maybe take a deep breath, write a note to help you focus, or take a drink of water. Consider which strengths will help and which you might need to dial up or down. For example, if kindness is your go-to, you may soften the message until it disappears. If bravery doesn’t come naturally, you may want to pray for courage. And finally, right before the talk, close your door and power pose for two minutes. It feels a little silly, but you’ll walk in more confident.

My client Carla found herself thinking about a conversation she needed to have with her staff member, Sandy, when she should have been focusing on her 7-year-old son. Why was she thinking about it then? Because, like most nonprofit leaders, she hadn’t found any other time to sort it out in her mind.

Carla’s team was getting ready for a walk to raise money for one of their programs. You’d think it would be simple enough to plan. But Sandy kept railroading her thoughts and opinions into every conversation and never gave anyone else a chance to share theirs. Everyone else was shutting down and checking out, and the walk was quickly becoming an event the whole staff wanted to avoid.

Carla had addressed similar issues with Sandy before and was sure that trying again would only make things worse. So when she brought it up in our coaching call, I suggested she PAUSE and take time to PONDER, which would let her prepare more intentionally and approach it differently this time.

We started with her belief that talking with Sandy about it would only make it worse. Was it true, or was it a story she’d been telling herself since the last conversation? Carla agreed to try to let that story go, hoping a talk could bring about change.
​
Carla wrote down specific examples of when Sandy had talked over the rest of the team. Then she got clear on her outcome: she wanted Sandy to leave the meeting feeling supported. Next, I helped Carla figure out what to do when Sandy’s defensiveness would trigger her. She decided she’d ground herself by holding her warm coffee cup and reminding herself, “It’s not about me. I’m here to help her grow. Breathe through it.”

After our call, Carla booked the conversation with Sandy for a morning when she’d have time to gather her thoughts, instead of letting it follow her home again.
​
Things didn’t change overnight. But Carla walked in confident. She knew she’d done her best to address the issue, and their relationship stayed intact instead of getting worse. 

What to say during a feedback conversation (PROCEED with your PEOPLE)

Now you’re ready for the conversation. This is often the hardest part and takes a bit of courage.

  • Engage as people. Make sure you’re somewhere you won’t get interrupted. Put your phone away and close your email. Put the relationship before the responsibility. That means connect with them as a person before you move on to the feedback.
  • Exchange your perspectives. Please, skip the compliment sandwich! People can see it coming, and they brace for the “but.” Instead, share what you noticed, plainly, and get curious about their side. Use how and what questions, and nix the why. “Why was it late?” sounds like an accusation and puts people on the defensive. “What will help you get paperwork in on time?” opens up a conversation.
  • Empower their solutions. Resist the urge to fix it for them. Get comfortable with silence. They often already know the answer, so give them room to find it. That takes trust, and trust builds over time, as they see it’s safe to be honest and that you’ll work with them on solutions.

What to do after you give feedback

Giving feedback isn’t a one-time thing. It’s part of ongoing supervision. Before you wrap up your conversation, agree on next steps for them and maybe for you. Let them know you’ll add it to your next one-to-one agenda. That’s where the accountability comes in. When you see the change, tell them, and name the strength they used to get there. If it doesn’t happen, you’ve noted the conversation, so it’s easy to pick it back up.

Make feedback a regular part of supervision

If you’re reading this thinking, “I barely have time for one-to-ones, never mind time to prepare for them,” you’re not alone. Most of us were promoted because we were good at the work, not because someone taught us how to supervise.
That’s why I created Staff Supervision That Transforms, a course inside The Training Library. It includes a supervision document template that you and your team member both add to, so feedback goes both ways and has a regular home instead of piling up. You’ll also get four pages of coaching questions for your one-to-ones, a before, during, and after checklist for every session, and a linked Training Library session on asking for feedback yourself.

Learn more about Staff Supervision That Transforms

Frequently asked questions about giving feedback

​Should I use the feedback sandwich?
No. Staff see it coming, brace for the “but,” and stop trusting your praise. Give positive feedback on its own, and often.

When is the best time to give feedback?
When you’ve had time to prepare, and you’re at your best. Avoid the end of a long day or squeezing it between back-to-back meetings.

What questions should I ask when giving feedback?
Ask open-ended how and what questions, like “What got in the way?” or “What would help next time?” Why questions can sound like accusations.

How do I give feedback without sounding critical?
Describe what you saw, the way a camera would have recorded it, then share the impact. Leave out labels like “rude” or “lazy.”
​
What if my employee gets defensive?
Plan for it ahead of time. Notice what triggers you, take a breath, and stay curious. Keep your eye on the outcome you planned and on the relationship.



We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart