$6,500 of Decorating vs. a $100K Renovation


The short answer: you may not need to replace dark espresso floors at all. In Manuela’s four-level Yorkville brownstone, new floors, stairs and banisters would have cost $100,000 or more. We spent $6,500 on decorating instead, adding contrast with chocolate, cognac and ochre, and the floors stayed.

Maria Killam and Manuela at the front door of Manuela's brownstone in Yorkville, Toronto

Today on Decorate or Renovate!?, I’m in Manuela’s brownstone in Yorkville. Eight years ago, she hired a designer to give her the look of a New York brownstone. Instead, she got beige and oatmeal. The house never felt finished. She told me her eyes had too many places to rest, and she’d started looking at her dark espresso floors, wondering if they were the culprit.

Before and after of Manuela's dining room: white chairs and a bright brushstroke canvas before, brown velvet chairs, cognac lamps and her gold-framed painting on the wall after

Replacing the floors and banisters on all four levels of a house like this would cost $100,000 or more, and it wouldn’t have fixed what was bothering her. What her rooms needed was contrast, and her best painting moved out of the corner and onto a wall where it could finally be the star. We spent $6,500 on decorating, and the floors stayed exactly where they are.

The next day, Manuela sent me this note:

Dear Maria and Vienna, thank you both for such a wonderful experience this week. Working with you was a real joy, and the house feels so special now! Safe travels, Manuela

If these were your floors, would you have ripped them out? Watch the whole makeover below.

If you live anywhere between Vancouver and Chilliwack, apply here to be on the show.

Questions About Dark Floors

Do I need to replace my dark espresso floors?

Not always. When a room feels unfinished, people often blame the floor for what the decorating is missing. In Manuela’s house, bringing chocolate, cognac and ochre into her neutrals gave the dark floors something to relate to, and they stayed. I explain when replacing them does make sense in When NOT to Replace Your Floors.

What colours work with dark espresso floors?

In this makeover, chocolate, cognac, ochre and gold against her neutrals did the job. Her rooms were all beige and oatmeal, so the dark floors were the only contrast in the house. Bringing in deeper, warmer colours gave the floors something to relate to.

How much does it cost to replace hardwood floors in a Toronto townhouse?

In Manuela’s four-level Yorkville brownstone, replacing the floors, stairs and banisters would have cost $100,000 or more. We spent $6,500 on decorating.

Why does my beige room feel unfinished?

Usually because there’s no contrast. When everything is the same beige and oatmeal, nothing stands out. In Manuela’s house, adding deeper colours and moving her best painting to a wall where it could be the focal point made the rooms feel finished.

What is Decorate or Renovate?

It’s my YouTube series, where I show homeowners when decorating can solve the problem they were planning to renovate their way out of.

Related posts:

Read This Before You Rip Out Your Grey Floors

The Orange Brick Fireplace Wasn’t the Problem

$85K Renovation Avoided

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart