

I went to see I Play Rocky at the cinema last night and one line really struck me: “Anyone can write”.
I suppose, in a way, that’s sort of true. Most people can be taught to write in one language or another and can put words on paper.
But there’s a big difference between writing words and crafting content. Whether that’s books, blog posts, film scripts or songs. Each has its own skills and nuances that are learned not natural. It takes years, if not decades, to hone your voice and learn to edit your first drafts, and most of us- myself included- aren’t nearly done learning.
This issue is at the heart of my review of Absent Witness by Paula Wilkes. Full Disclosure: I was sent a review copy of this book by the author. It’s not all bad, but there’s definitely room for improvement.
Usually, when I request review copies, I do some research first. But I was coming off the back of what was either flu or COVID-19 and feeling rough, and all I saw was that she was from Somerset. I bloody love the West Country, and I adore supporting writers from the area, so I went ahead and asked for a review copy.
While digital copies are cheaper for the author, I always see if I can get a physical review copy as I find them easier to read. I was very grateful to be sent it, and interested to see what it held.
The first red flag was on the back. The author image was clearly an AI- generated cartoon. Next to it was a very generic bio that told the reader nothing about the author.
I immediately went searching, and found more signs of AI. The author had no online presence that I could see before she began publishing her books, and most, if not all, of her social media posts are AI- generated. Her website is generic, and filled with AI cartoons, although there are a few real photos.
Most of the books have been published in the last year, and there are at least 8 of them to my knowledge. About one a month appears to be the schedule, and there’s everything from romance and kid’s books to the crime fiction of Absent Witness.
Concerned, I asked the author if the book was AI. Her response was that ‘some of’ her books were published this year because she’d been writing them while caring for an elderly relative, and only just found the time to publish them. As for AI, she says that she can’t afford to hire a graphic designer to make her social media posts. She skipped over my concerns about the AI-generated images of herself.
There’s a few issues with this response, as much as taking care of others is valiant and admirable. The first is that from what I can see all her books listed on her website were published this year, not a few. While she did publish with a vanity publisher before this year, the majority of her recent books were all launched in 2026. Also, you don’t need to use AI for social media posts: stock images or pictures you took yourself would do.
AI is highly damaging for the planet and humanity, so avoiding it is always the best approach. I understand some people played with it when it first came out, as it seemed harmless then, but we now know the issues it causes, and should be more aware of our use of it.
You can also use other people’s work and collaborate, with the right attribution, instead of using AI, which runs on stolen data from those with actual skills. For example, here’s a really good cartoon from Twonks by Steve Nelson which illustrates the attitude of AI “artists”.

I can sympathise with someone who took care of others, and since there were a few real pictures among the cartoons, I gave the book a go.
The first thing you notice is that no one else is credited with anything. I can see it’s self-published, but there’s no editor, no heartfelt dedication, not even the name of the company that printed it.
The writing itself had at least some support from a human. You can see that from the typos and some of the stylistic choices. It’s not actually a bad book. There’s some potential, even if it needs a lot of work.
The dialogue is punchy and sharp, and the plot itself, while formulaic, does work well. The issue is there’s no character development, or building of the setting, the fictional town of Wraithcombe.
DCI Rowan Calder could be literally any 90s-style detective: rough, angry and driven. And that’s about it.
The book is gripping and interesting in an offhand sort of way. To be honest, it’ll be difficult to remember much of it after a few days, but there are some passages and depictions that stick with you.
At best, it’s simple, easy-reading crime fiction that’s the equivalent of Mills And Boon for thriller readers. It won’t blow you away, but if you’re looking for something quick and easy to read, it’ll do the job.
The issue here is the marketing and the way it’s done. The author doesn’t want to spend money marketing her work, but she’s actually cheapening her brand by using AI to generate cartoons of herself when a selfie would do.
Also, writing isn’t something you do well instantly. Self-publishing is great, as it allows people without connections in the publishing market to get a foothold and share their work. But it isn’t a get-rich-and-famous-quick solution.
Even if, as the author said, she wrote all these books in one go, you don’t need to publish them all in a few months. The best approach is to publish slowly, and to learn from each book. Work with readers and beta readers, and as you grow, editors, to learn how to grow your books and build a series.
The DCI Calder series appears to have at least 5 books in it already, all published within weeks of each other. This isn’t enough time to learn and see what readers liked and make tweaks.
This approach reminds me a lot of those people who get tattooed under anesthetic because they want to be heavily tattooed instantly and don’t want to go through the process of healing, building colour etc. They just want an instant body suit.
Wanting to be a prolific writer instantly means you miss out on a lot, like the human connection between writers, readers, editors and others in the industry.
The author attends a lot of local craft fairs etc, but doesn’t go to literary festivals or interact with other writers.
There’s clearly a human behind all this, and from what I can see, one who is retired from banking and lives in Somerset. Someone like that has the time and resources to learn and grow as a writer, rather than trying to jump the gun.
So, in conclusion, I think this is an author to watch out for. I don’t think this is some guy cosplaying as 6 different author avatars and seeing what sticks.
Instead, it’s someone who thinks AI and self-publishing are shortcuts to get their work out there, and that since they wrote their work already, there’s no need for edits or collaboration.
With time, work, and an avoidance of ChatGPT, they could enhance their writing, improve their marketing and grow their reach. They’re clearly trying hard, and I don’t want to disparage that. Reaching out to a human-led blog like this is a start, but real humans spot AI marketing and short cuts a mile off.
It’s clearly a sign of the times that I’m getting more and more AI-marketed books review and interview requests. I never platform anything that doesn’t at least have a human somewhere at the back of it.
There’s a real person here, and with time and work, their writing could be worth a read. For now, find self-published authors who are putting in the graft and have the skills needed to craft great fiction.
As for Paula Wilkes and Absent Witness, watch this space. She may improve and grow. She may not. But there is potential here and we’ll just have to see what she does with it.
UPDATE: The author has requested an update with all the new facts I have after she moaned that I was incorrect, while providing no evidence. She claims to have over 4500 Facebook followers on her ‘books by Paula Wilkes’ page and claims she was previously published by traditional publishers- which was actually a vanity publisher that you can pay, and that she does pay marketers. She supplied no proof and just demanded I update it, and since I don’t like being called a liar, here is the only evidence I could find to refute her claims- the rest is just nothing cos she couldn’t prove any of it and I can’t prove a negative. I couldn’t find any books published under the same name beyond the self-published from this year and one from the vanity publisher, and I can see no evidence of a marketing agency’s involvement. She claims she wrote everything, but she doesn’t understand that if you’re inauthentic and use AI, you destroy all your credibility. It’s sucks but there might not be an improvement. Only time will tell.
