Iowa Late Proof of Loss


An insurance company’s own witness testified that a late-filed proof of loss did not affect its investigation or adjustment of a claim. The company had received notice the day after the storm, inspected the property, and paid more than $170,000. Yet the homeowners lost their right to pursue additional actual cash value benefits because their proof of loss was late. That result deserves a closer look.

In a recently decided case, Kooiker v. Auto-Owners Insurance Company, 1 the homeowners suffered substantial wind damage on May 21, 2024. They reported the loss the following day. Auto-Owners investigated through an independent adjuster and paid $170,545.81 in actual cash value for structural damage on July 16, 2024.

The homeowners later disagreed with the amount of the adjustment. On April 15, 2025, they submitted a proof of loss identifying an actual cash value of $602,245.11. Auto-Owners rejected their proposed scope and later reinspected the property. The court found that the proof was submitted 269 days after the policy deadline. Ultimately, the court granted summary judgment for the insurer, including on the homeowners’ claim for additional actual cash value benefits, based in part on the proof of loss being filed too late.

I understand that policy conditions matter. The trial court order states that Auto-Owners reminded the homeowners of the proof requirement six times. That fact certainly does not help the policyholders. But Iowa law also recognizes substantial compliance, waiver or excuse, and lack of prejudice as grounds for avoiding forfeiture. Those principles should have practical meaning.

The testimony reproduced in the order is what caught my attention. Auto-Owners’ witness, Dan Slater, was asked: “Was [Defendants’] investigation of the claim or adjustment process affected at all by the delay in returning Proof of Loss?” His answer began with a remarkably useful word for the policyholders: “No.”

He explained that the company had continued handling the claim and paid the actual cash value amount based on its estimate without receiving the form. When asked whether the company had been able to go through adjustment without it, he answered, “The initial stages of it, yes.” Counsel then followed up: “Any stages that were affected?” Slater responded: “No. Because no work had or has been completed. So we have not issued out any recoverable depreciation or anything which may require having that form.”

If I represented these homeowners, I would certainly want the jury to hear that testimony. It came from the insurance company’s own witness and directly addressed whether the delay affected the process the proof was supposedly needed to facilitate. His qualification concerning unfinished repairs also makes it important to distinguish the adjustment of actual cash value from later payment of recoverable depreciation.

The court nevertheless found that the homeowners had not overcome Iowa’s presumption of prejudice from their noncompliance. I recognize that Iowa places that burden on the policyholder in these circumstances. My concern is that the homeowners presented evidence from which a reasonable jury could find that the late proof caused no prejudice. Defeating the insurer’s summary judgment motion should not require conclusively proving the entire case before trial.

This brings me back to a question I explored in “Where Did the Proof of Loss Requirement in a Property Insurance Policy Originate? What Was Its Original Purpose.” We ought to understand what a policy requirement was intended to accomplish before allowing it to defeat an otherwise valid claim.

In “Proof of Loss Requirements: A 222-Year-Old Case Still Relevant for Modern Insurance Claims,” I discussed Lenox v. United Insurance Company, 2 an 1802 marine insurance decision. Justice Kent described the preliminary documents as providing “reasonable information or notice, upon which he is to act.” The policy wording was different from today’s detailed sworn-proof provisions, but the practical insight remains valuable. Preliminary proof enables the insurer to respond to a loss.

Today, prompt notice ordinarily gives the insurance company the opportunity to send its adjusters, consultants, engineers, and investigators. They can photograph the damage, take measurements, ask questions, and prepare estimates. Once the parties are actively exchanging information and adjusting the loss, a later sworn form may add little to what the insurer already knows or could have determined once it knows of the loss.

A sworn proof can still supply useful information concerning ownership, mortgages, other insurance, and the policyholder’s position about the amount claimed. But these matters are trivial from a time-sensitive standpoint. Treating a late-filed proof of loss as grounds for forfeiture, after its investigative purpose has been accomplished, strikes me as an outdated technical approach to modern claims handling. A form should help move adjustment forward. Its absence should be evaluated in light of what actually happened.

The critical factual question in this case should have been what Auto-Owners could no longer determine because the proof arrived late. An item-by-item comparison of the initial adjustment and the supplemental submission would help answer that question. Were the homeowners identifying previously undisclosed damage that could no longer be evaluated? Or were they disagreeing about the scope, repair methods, and pricing for damage Auto-Owners had already inspected?

Those circumstances could produce very different answers about prejudice. If evidence disappeared or conditions changed so significantly that additional damage could not fairly be investigated, the insurer would have a stronger argument. The opinion does not adequately explain how such a specific impairment overcame the significance of its own witness’s testimony.

The trial court also relied on lost opportunities to negotiate and conduct a timely investigation. Yet Auto-Owners received next-day notice and actually investigated. Its later reinspection was a second opportunity to inspect the property. The date of that second visit does not, by itself, establish that the company lost its first opportunity.

One cited decision, Bruns v. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Company, 407 N.W.2d 576 (Iowa 1987), involved insurers receiving no notice of an automobile collision for twenty-eight months. The lost opportunity to inspect the original scene and vehicles is readily understandable. Applying that reasoning to an insurer that promptly received notice and inspected requires a much closer examination of what the delayed proof prevented it from doing. Again, the late notice of loss seems the paramount issue in that case.

The Kooiker order separately addressed replacement cost benefits. The homeowners admitted that they had not given the required notice of intent to repair or completed repairs within the required period. Those present different contractual issues. My concern here is the loss of the opportunity to establish additional actual cash value benefits for damage the insurer had already been given an opportunity to investigate.

There is also a practical lesson, and I do not want anybody to miss it while agreeing with my criticism of the decision. When the insurance company asks for a proof of loss, file a proof of loss. Read the policy as well, because some deadlines run without a separate request. Calendar the deadline, address the required information, execute the form properly, and keep evidence of delivery.

Do not wait for the perfect estimate while the deadline expires. Loss adjustment is a developing process. A timely proof should reflect the insured’s best supported, good-faith knowledge and belief, with estimates and unresolved matters clearly explained. Where permitted, preserve the ability to supplement as additional information becomes available. An estimate that later changes is different from a statement the insured knows is inaccurate. Nobody should sign a sworn form carelessly or assume that a placeholder satisfies the policy.

If more time is needed, promptly request an extension and obtain the insurer’s agreement in writing. An unanswered request is not an extension. Neither is the assumption that an open claim file means the insurer has abandoned its deadlines. Public adjusters and policyholders should treat these requirements seriously even while arguing that their technical enforcement can produce an unjust result.

I believe the testimony quoted in this ruling should have been persuasive enough to overcome any question of prejudice. The policyholders would still have had to prove the amount owed. Giving them that opportunity would have respected both the purpose of the proof requirement and the evidence that Auto-Owners had been able to do its job. It would also have avoided a technical forfeiture of the contract benefits.

Thought For The Day

“The life of the law has not been logic: it has been experience.”
—Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.


1 Kooiker v. Auto-Owners Ins. Co., No. 4:25-cv-00327 (S.D. Iowa Nov. 9, 2026).

2 Lenox v. United Ins. Co., 3 Johns.Cas. 224 (NY Sup. Ct. (1802).



We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Som2ny Network
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart